Thrift Stores near Bay Shore, NY

16 locations found near Bay Shore

“ALWAYS CLEAN!
Love this thrift store! You can tell they take care of presenting the clothes. The isles are categorized by size, category, and along with color! My ocd loves how organized everything perfectly is!
They have wonderful prices and even offer 50% off specific colored tags assigned to that day.
The one thing that I REALLY REALLY love is that they offer a changing room, which most thrift stores are eliminating.
There's nothing negative to say!
Great prices!
Great staff!
Great environment!
100/100”

3.5 Good59 Reviews

“The two guys who were working there when I went were so nice. The atmosphere was well organized. Vintage antiques from 60s-2000s. Also some international finds. A little pricey but overall great experience.”

4.9 Superb111 Reviews

“My mom and I love coming to this shop! There are so many interesting and unique pieces. We’ve spent hours there just looking through the different items, and are always finding something neat! Some are decently priced while others seem higher in comparison to similar pieces from other vintage shops.”

4.7 Superb153 Reviews

“The bargains are EXPLOSIVE so many nice things with great prices. There is something for everyone in this store and the owners BOTH are extremely generous nice people. the deals are crazy. this is a must visit spot.”

4.6 Superb99 Reviews

“Pretty good store I’ve recently gotten into collecting physical media & they had a bunch of cd options so I picked up a few, prices were pretty reasonable I got quite a few for just $10 would’ve been 10 a piece anywhere else so I can’t really complain. Def wanna come back to check out DVDs since I collect those too!”

4.5 Superb81 Reviews

“This place is awesome and one of my favorite thrift shops to go to. The prices are great, the set up of the store is nice and the people that work there are very friendly. The one gentleman, I wish I knew his name, I think maybe tom but not positive, is so nice and helpful to all. If you’re looking for a local thrift to go to this is the one. Highly highly recommend.”

4.8 Superb48 Reviews

“Anthony and Scott picked up my donated furniture and were truly incredible. They were kind, professional, and incredibly efficient. The entire process was smooth and stress-free thanks to them. Awesome guys!!”

4.2 Good145 Reviews

“Came here for the first time with my friend. We absolutely LOVED being there. Betty Ann was super friendly! Lots of awesome things to look at, with no pressure to purchase anything. We will be back!!!”

4.6 Superb41 Reviews

“Awesome team inside. Can see and hear just how they appreciate each other and the people whom come in. This place has good prices, inventory changed frequently which is fantastic. HOWEVER it’s the people that volunteer / work here that is the best. Truly good caring hardworking and attentive people. God Bless you all”

4.6 Superb7 Reviews

“Best thrift store I've been in. The place is small but Everytime I've gone in there, I've found amazing deals. The owner is very friendly as well. I plan to be a regular here.”

4.5 Superb20 Reviews

“What a wonderful little store..the staff is so kind and sweet.
The merchandise is amazing..sometimes you will find that long lost pin your grandmother wore. Or maybe that blazer your mom had back in the day.
But dont be shocked if you find a rack of brand new clothes..
Their hours are 11-3 and they only take cash
Happy shopping
Update:: they now take credit cards and apple pay.. the ladies are still absolutely wonderful. The store gives you a back in time vibe..its absolutely perfect..”

3.3 Good32 Reviews

“I love this savers, Marlon, Nora and Cheryl are the best!!!! They are always very helpful and always so nice. They greet everyone with a smile, and if you have a hard time at the register they are more than happy to help you. They are top tier! Marlon, Nora and Cheryl are always approachable not like some of the other employees. Patrick is the best store manager of any of the savers I have gone too. Cheryl is an absolute doll, and has so much patience even when she is super busy . When she is working her area is very organized.”

3.4 Good141 Reviews

“This is a well stocked store with two floors of merchandise. The staff is friendly. Most of the items are in excellent condition and the store is kept fairly orderly.”

2.9 Average67 Reviews

“Hey probably it was my lucky day the owner I think extremely nice …. the guys that helped me with furniture Nice …..
Extremely nice , the place it’s clean

Yes there was dining sets for over $2000 but hey you pick up what’s good for your pocket!”

2.6 Average77 Reviews