-
March 2020 by John Ziegler
First time at Riesterers. Heard about it for many years. Absolutely delicious! One of the best bakeries on Long Island! Will be back!
-
March 2020 by Barry H.
If you have a sweet tooth, I advise you to stay as far away from this bakery as possible. But if you cannot resist then I recommend the cakes the cupcakes the pastries the donuts the pies the novelties the specialties the breads the crackers and pretty much everything on the lower shelves all the way up to the upper shelves and the shelves behind the counter as well.
-
February 2020 by Allison L.
This is a solid bakery that has been here for a long time. Got some cupcakes from her for my daughter's party when it was at the Long Island Children's museum. It was yummy. Have gone back for the holiday gingerbread house. Not as glamorized as some other bakeries but many good choices.
-
February 2020 by Noa A.
Best bakery! They really know how to create the best desserts! I recommend everything on the menu
-
January 2020 by Regina Haffey Kilkenny
Riesterer’s made our beautiful three-tiered wedding cake with three different fillings. As delicious as it was beautiful! They are amazing!
-
January 2020 by Christina S.
What a wonderful beautiful cake you've made to celebrate my daughter's first birthday. It was delicious and we received many compliments.
-
December 2019 by Ekaterina Richman
The place have moved to hempstead location, non of which is mentioned here. At least to make an effort not to waste your customers time and update google info which doesn’t take that long, an email away. Cakes are good but not sure if stays same in new location
-
December 2019 by Jason B.
This is just reviewing 2 items I tried. The diamond rainbow cookie was pretty good. 4/5. The jelly donut was not good. It was better than Dunkin donuts but the dough had little flavor and the jelly did not taste like any fruit in particular. It was red so I assume it was supposed to be raspberry. The service was very nice and there seems to be a wide selection of cakes, cookies pies and breads.
-
November 2019 by Jordan Qanon Brock
Smelled great the people behind the counter very nice and professional. I tried one of there large cookies. There are another 200 items I didn’t try so I gave to go back at least another 199 times
-
November 2019 by Caren K.
Go to them with an idea and they make it happen! The cake tasted as good as it looked. They can do anything. Staff is accommodating.
-
November 2019 by Karen Santangelo
So upset the other day to see they closed down for good......they had a sign saying they were moving to a bakery in west Hempstead, but I know for myself theres nothing worse than a bakery cupcake they are always stale!!!! Looking for a new place asap!!!
-
October 2019 by Richa T.
We came here the other day to grab a birthday cake and it was absolutely amazing! Pros: + Delicious variety - we ended up trying out the German chocolate cake + beautifully decorated + Extra points for bakeries that are family owned + generally pretty fresh cakes/pastries Cons: - A little pricey
-
October 2019 by S S.
The Cake Gallery is simply the best place to get a birthday cake. I got a cake for my mother's 70th Birthday Party and is was absolutely fantastic. Everyone raved about the cake. It is the perfect consistency of soft icing and fresh cake. I highly recommend anyone that needs a cake to go here. Make sure you go at least a week early to order the cake. I waited till last minute but I was accommodated but to make it easier on the establishment order early.
-
October 2019 by Jessica G.
I've ordered two cakes from Tom at the cake gallery in the past two months and both cakes tasted just as good as they looked! Everyone loved how cute they came out and couldn't get enough of the delicious the cookies and cream filling! Thank you Cake Gallery!
-
September 2019 by agizmo1
Riester's Bakery has been there for more then the thirty years I have lived hear. There cakes are top notch but a little pricy$$$,
