Insurance near Bethpage, NY

30 locations found near Bethpage

“Switched from Geico to Allstate- Scott was so helpful from start to finish. Amazing customer service and made the process of switching so easy. Anytime I have to contact Scott he always replies so quickly and super helpful.”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“Jesse is the best! As a driver with 2 years of experience, he found me the best rates I could find on Long Island, and he also did the same when I had only been driving for 1 year.”

5 Superb193 Reviews

“Mr. Elbogen....and all his staff are extremely highly trained professionals.
They have all been helping myself and my family members and a multitude of my friends, with their Supreme service. , ...they truly have astute working knowledge of all lines of insurance. They make us feel like truly valued customers, answer all of our concerns, offer top knotch advice, truly and amazing group of true humanitarians......I am 62 years old and have been with state farm since I was 18 years of age. I urge, and implore all people to please use this state farm agency. You will not be disappointed as their level of intelligence and insightfullness of ins is truly amazing.
Please I urge you to give them a call.
Especially with the new market place increases. Excellent group of what a true professional us. ? C
ordially, Laura Scundakis

UPDATED REVIEW WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 03, 2025

Customer Service rep Miss Sanjida is wonderful and excellent and helped me with all my needs. She is one of the many outstanding reasons why I have stayed with State Farm for over the last 4 decades. Please give this delightful individual a five star rating. Thank you.
Laura Scundakis”

5 Superb178 Reviews

“I highly recommend Joseph Benincasa and his team at State Farm! A special shoutout to Fabrianna, who has been an absolute pleasure to work with. From answering my initial call to promptly responding to all of my questions via email, she has been incredibly helpful throughout the entire process.

As a nervous first-time homebuyer, I truly appreciate how smooth and stress-free she has made everything. I will definitely be recommending Joseph, Fabrianna, and the entire team to all of my friends and family. They’re the best!

Thank you again for all of your help!”

5 Superb157 Reviews

“Joe and Dan, the gem of a man who personally assisted me in a Herculean same day transaction, are the Baryshnikov’s (spelling?) of Insurance. They are superb—great expedient service, super knowledge of their offerings; their level of professionalism, amiability, care, and reasonable rates can’t be beat! My utmost recommendation goes to these great folks at State Farm!”

5 Superb139 Reviews

“Thank you, Ruth, from State Farm for an amazing, seamless, and thorough experience! Ruth was quick to take my calls, answer my questions and was kind, attentive, and patient, offering my wife and I just the assistance we needed. I can't thank Ruth enough for putting our minds at ease, helping us with our questions and looking out for our best interests! With something that started off stressfully at the beginning of the day, once Ruth stepped in all of our concerns had been rectified. She is an incredible member of the team and the reason we continue to stay with State Farm.”

5 Superb107 Reviews

“Good local office. It's nice to be able to get someone on the phone who knows the area. Most recently worked with Andrew Ross, who made updating my auto policy easy.”

5 Superb118 Reviews

“I had an excellent experience working with Jazline. From the very beginning she was patient, knowledgeable, and incredibly helpful in guiding me through the process of obtaining insurance. She took the time to explain every detail clearly, answered all of my questions, and made sure I felt supported and guided every step of the way. Their professionalism and dedication truly stood out. What could have been a stressful process became smooth and straightforward because of her assistance. I’m extremely grateful for her help and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable and personalized service. Jazline really took a lot of weight off my shoulders and I will definitely be recommending her to anyone looking for any type of insurance.”

4.9 Superb121 Reviews

“John made getting car insurance quick and easy. He explained everything clearly, was very helpful, and made sure I got the coverage that worked best for me. Definitely recommend him!”

4.9 Superb121 Reviews

“Lydia very respectful, helpful and professional. Sounded in awesome mood when I spoke with her on the phone. Keep up the great work. Happy Thanksgiving to all of you????”

4.9 Superb100 Reviews

“It is really a great experience working with Joyce Petitto all these years. She is very friendly, professional, reliable, helpful, and her patience goes beyond limit. Thank you Joyce!. I won't leave behind the entire team. They're all very polite and helpful. My family and I have been with this office for over 20 years”

5 Superb60 Reviews

“Janice handled my insurance needs very professionally. It was a great experience in dealing with an insurance agent. She explained everything and took care of canceling my previous coverages. I would recommend her for anyone who is looking for a new coverage and Statefarm is our next door neighbor !!”

4.9 Superb81 Reviews

“Bob Masterson’s State Farm has been our go-to insurance provider for about 30 years - car, home, life -all through State Farm . We work primarily with John Tyson , who has always gone above and beyond whether it be making adjustments to policies to something that makes more sense for us , or claims advice on the occasions where we have needed it . I have occasionally reached out to John after business hours , on evenings / weekends and there is never a hesitation in getting a pleasant and thorough response . So refreshing to have a friendly , and familiar voice to answer urgent claims questions in a crisis situation . You know what they say - like a good neighbor … ! 5-stars and a great big thank you to Bob Masterson’s office for 30 years of thorough and professional customer service -highly recommend !”

4.9 Superb70 Reviews

“Very professional and caring Insurance Agency. The owner, Robert Zabbia and his staff especially the Office Manager Denise provide excellent service. Even with escalating insurance premiums, they will work very hard to get you the best premium for the best coverage. The Zabbia Agency has been my Insurance agency for over 15 years.”

4.9 Superb66 Reviews

“We have been with State Farm Sean McCarthy Agency for over 42 years. The rates they charge are affordable for the coverage you get. Claims are Quick & EASY! The representatives are very Professional and friendly.
I hope to be ther another 42 years.”

4.8 Superb104 Reviews

“Getting a quote from Mike Rogers was fast and easy. I saved money when compared to other quotes
I received on my car insurance. It was a very positive experience.”

4.9 Superb64 Reviews

“Dear. Staff supervisor Ms. Sandra Simpson. I Honestly will share with you that I experienced a great relief by meeting with Tatiana F. & Linda L. they both implemented a great personality with an excellent sense of humor including a magnificent indication of working skills. I'm grateful for my decision of be came a costumer of your staff @ the State Farm auto & home owner insurance. Again thank you both Tatiana & Linda ,sincerely yours Mr. Rodolfo G, ( Rudy ) Rios”

4.8 Superb114 Reviews

“Dear State Farm Team,

I am writing to recognize the exceptional service I consistently receive from your representative, Karen. I called just to get a car insurance quote for my daughter with the 1(800) number, but Karen went far beyond their service. She took the time to listen, thoroughly explain our options, and help us clear up a misunderstanding we had regarding coverage for my daughter.
Her professionalism, patience, and genuine willingness to assist turned what could have been a stressful situation into an easy and reassuring experience. Because of Karen’s stellar support, we feel confident, respected, and truly valued as State Farm customers.
I wanted to be sure her efforts are acknowledged. Karen is the reason we are proud and happy to remain with State Farm.

Thank you”

4.9 Superb69 Reviews

“I recently switched to State Farm for my car insurance, and I couldn't be happier with my decision. From the start, Marcela Ruppert customer service was exceptional. The representative Joe Q. I spoke with was knowledgeable, patient and took the time to explain all the coverage options available to me.

They have a fast response time when emailing with questions, competitive rates and offer discounts.

Overall, I highly recommend State Farm for anyone looking for reliable and affordable car insurance. Their excellent customer service and comprehensive coverage options make them a top choice in my book.”

5 Superb45 Reviews

“Thanks to Brandon Schlott, we feel very good about our decision to choose Allstate for our Home and Auto insurance, especially confident knowing Brandon Schlott is there to advise and help when necessary.”

5 Superb44 Reviews

“Maria helped me get an insurance policy for my drone before a big trip. The process was extremely easy and the rates were unbeatable. I recommend reaching out to her if you need any insurance needs!”

5 Superb65 Reviews

“Outstanding service...professional, responsive, and truly cares about their clients. They made the process quick, stress-free, and easy to understand. Highly recommend!”

4.9 Superb67 Reviews

“I had a fantastic experience working with Lilian. She is extremely responsive, and knowledgeable. I was a first time homebuyer, new resident of Long Island (came from FL), and first time getting a car here in NY. She was a great resource and gave me a lot of thoughts and considerations as I went through my home purchase/closing process and car purchase. She made any steps I needed to take clear and concise. She was truly a pleasure to work with, always taking the time to answer my questions and explain everything clearly. I would highly recommend her services to anyone looking for a reliable and professional insurance agent.”

4.9 Superb50 Reviews

“This agency has been very responsive to my needs. In the past they reviewed my car insurance, thinking it would be more expensive, but they came back with a more affordable alternative with same coverage.”

4.8 Superb75 Reviews

““Tom Whalen and his team at Allstate always go above and beyond. They make everything easy to understand and are always there when you need them. Great people, great service.”
Tom runs a top notch agency and you will be happy to have him and his team on your side for all your insurance needs.”

5 Superb35 Reviews

“Ive been shopping for insurance since yesterday. I was shot down by geico, progressive and every other place i could possibly call in a day. Today while my wife was getting an inspection done on her vehicle at Midas, I randomly walked into an Allstate office on sunrise hwy in seaford ny…. I walked in with ZERO expectations on getting a quote. I explained my situation to the lovely ladies at the office and I have to say.. LUCY PATTERSON!!! Omg!! Heaven sent!! She sat at that computer and vigorously punched at that keyboard with no concern for her manicured fingers and gave me the ABSOLUTE best quote which I ultimately believed was impossible!!! I walked out of that office with my head held high and an insured vehicle!!! Thank you so much Lucy! God bless you!!!!’”

4.9 Superb42 Reviews

“I stopped by the Ricardo Mercado Allstate agency to add a vehicle to my policy. Sales manager, Lianny Hernandez who greeted me with a warm, friendly smile then assisted me right away with the paperwork and emailing the proper documents to all the right parties and had a temporary policy card ready for me within a few minutes. Thanks to the courtesy and professionalism of Ms. Hernandez my experience at this Allstate agency was fast, efficient With reasonable pricing. Thanks again!!!”

4.9 Superb35 Reviews

“Not only am I personally insured by Statefarm, I also work for a company who is insured by Statefarm so I speak to them on a regular basis. From the beginning Isabella and Norma have been my go-to girls for all my insurance needs. They are always willing and able to help when needed and I couldn't be more grateful for such an amazing team. Thank you both so much.”

4.7 Superb72 Reviews

“Robert respects the fact that I don’t have a computer and I don’t know how to use one so I prefer things done in the mail or on the phone. Thank you, Robert.”

5 Superb24 Reviews

“We have been working with agent, Lourdes Crespo. She provides my real estate brokerage with consistent, professional service. Her attention to detail and customer service make her a valuable asset to Complete Home Realty.”

5 Superb34 Reviews