-
April 2024 by Robert S.
Varney's is our go-to place for lunch or dinner. Every aspect of this cozy little restaurant is consistently satisfying. The menu, drink selection and wait staff make for a welcoming experience any day of the week.
-
April 2024 by Richard Hamill
Great food, friendly people. Always a good meal.
-
April 2024 by Gwen Pidgeon
Hometown Long Island. Outstanding, friendly, authentic Long Island servers perform like a synchronized team delivering lightning fast service. Ordered mussels in white (also available in red) served with an oven toasted slender loaf of garlic bread. The broth was very delicious, gently garlic.Parking: Easy to navigate parking lot located directly on Montauk Highway
-
March 2024 by Steve C.
Always a solid choice. Had high expectations of the mussels and they delivered. I needed more garlics bread to soak up the amazing sauce.
-
March 2024 by J Dolce
Delicious every time! From the mussels in red sauce to baked clams and fish sandwich, served up fresh and hot. Don’t forget the onion soup or chowder/bisque! And There’s plenty of choices for the landlubber! The staff are attentive and friendly. Stop by and enjoy!
-
March 2024 by Fred T.
Service 10 food 9 price 9 .waitress was unbelievable & for $30.00 I got shrimp cocktail 30 muscles wht.clam sauce baked classic bisque soup and Italian bread
-
March 2024 by Fred “Trigger” Truglio
Very attentive and delicious, quaint &
-
February 2024 by Kathy Hutton
Called and asked about "sea salt" as my husband is allergic, Praise God they do not use it. We were picking up at the Copart just a short walk from Varney's. So we walked down, enjoyed the atmosphere and the service was outstanding. He had the bowl of chili and I had the cold Lobster Roll and fries. It was AMAZING! If we come back again to Copart, we'll definitely come back to Varney's.
-
February 2024 by Nicholas L.
I love finding local gems when I travel and this is for sure one of those spots. I wanted some fried sea food and they didn't disappoint. Ended up starting with sea food bisque and it was great. Never had anything like it so not much to compare to, but with crackers it was pretty great. We also had wings for the table (Buffalo) and the fry was perfect. Could have been spicier but that's just my opinion. Buddy had lobster tacos, which is not a thing but he asked them and they made it happen. I got a sea food platter with cod and clams. The breading was light, good crunch and a bit of cornmeal. I really enjoyed it. Only thing I wasn't in love with was the fries. They were bland, crinkle fries from a frozen bag I'm sure. A shame when everything else was so fresh and perfect. It's very small too. So get there early or at not so busy times. Service was amazing. Super friendly, super knowledgeable and made awesome recommendations. Even the local beer I had (blue point toasted lager) went perfect with my meal. All that for $100. Not bad at all. If I'm ever back in Long Island for business, I'd come again.
-
February 2024 by Anthony T.
The whole belly fried clams were fresh unbelievably good, The mussels great. I wasn't disappointed at all. The place, crowd & service was all good.
-
January 2024 by Sam Hyatt
It’s a quaint little place in the middle of an unexpected area in Brookhaven NY on Long Island and these Lobster rolls with the most amazing slaw I have ever had were delicious. Topped that with two cold bud lights with my beautiful wife and honestly I would drive back from Texas to have them again!! Thanks for delicious surprise!
-
January 2024 by daniel ryan
Great place to grab some lunch if you're in the neighborhood.Service was friendly and excellent. Pasta cooked to
-
January 2024 by Randy Miano
Best food and service in the area!!!!
-
January 2024 by K Hispanski
Amazing food in a cozy little spot. Highly recommended!
-
December 2023 by Joelle Romano
I have loved Varney's for many years, but was not crazy about my food choice this time around. I ordered the chicken cesar wrap and essentially did not eat it. The dressing did not taste right at all.I will say, though a little on the pricey side, every other thing on that menu is out of this world!!
