The Company Store in Cheshire, NY, is a charming and unique community spot that offers much more than just a gas station. Housed in a historic 100-year-old former schoolhouse, it welcomes visitors with friendly staff, wonderful aromas, and a beautiful coffee bar crafted by a local artisan. The store provides a variety of freshly baked cookies, homemade salads, and pizza made from scratch, along with a selection of sandwiches with sliced, fresh meats. Its grocery shelves are stocked with essential items, and a grab-and-go section offers foods prepared on-site for quick meals. Customers can enjoy a wide array of beverages stored in glass cases, making it convenient for both locals and travelers. Beyond groceries, the store features a deli, a charming little bakery, and a well-curated selection of local artisan goods and antiques upstairs in the Cheshire Union. This space includes artist studios, an art classroom, and areas for local artists and vendors to display and sell their work, creating a vibrant community hub. The owners are known for their professionalism and warm interactions, making each visit a pleasant experience, although some visitors have noted that customer service can vary. The Company Store is especially appreciated by those heading to the beach, picnics, boating, or events like CMAC, as it offers a convenient stop for food and essentials. It combines the charm of a small-town store with the convenience of a modern, welcoming marketplaceāmaking it a favorite stop for locals and travelers alike.
Perfect little spot with the perfect little staff. You might stop for gas and end up with pizza and sandwiches for entire the family. The location is prime considering the closest grocery store is 25 minutes away.
October 2025
Has super friendly staff and had a lovely experience here
August 2025
I ordered a couple of pizzas on Monday to be picked up at noon. I had a garlic pizza and a pizza supreme. Both pizzas were excellent and I would gladly purchase pizza here given the opportunity in the future. There is no need to run to Canandaigua to get a pizza when you can get such a fine product right here in Cheshir