-
February 2024 by William Ringhoff
Hometown
-
February 2024 by edward martin
Great pizzas!
-
February 2024 by I Don’t Know
One of the workers in his 30s constantly flirts with a minor who works at the king kullen next door who’s stated she has a bf. Very
-
February 2024 by Cathy Clayton
I ordered veal marsala that had NO marsala wine in it! Why advertise it as "Marsala" if it is void of the wine? It tasted more like a thick, "flour" gravy. Not good at all and highly disappointed. Plus, all the food is super salty.
-
December 2023 by Meghan Pilkington
I had a great experience here my first time and keep going back. Everyone is super kind and prompt with all my orders. Best classic pizza out there too 10/10!!
-
November 2023 by Bill L.
I try to buy the $15 special pizza on Wednesday night I didn't realize the price of the pizza was $15.75. When I questioned the amount that they charge me they didn't explain to me the price is $15.75 I made a mistake when I called the manager he was very rude trying to make me feel I'm bothering him cause I questioned the price I would never go back to that restaurant just for the fact he stated you'd beating me up for .75 Very Rude go to Carlos pizza
-
October 2023 by Nishant T.
Every Long Islander needs their go-to bagel shop and pizza shop. This has quickly become my regular spot -- great location next to CVS and King Kullen with ample parking. I love their eggplant parm on hero, and their grandma slices are fantastic. Call in the order and you'll save time -- it's a busy place in a cozy space, with take out and dine-in. Great group of guys behind the counter who take pride in what they do and seem like they're having a good time doing it -- though sometimes I feel like I'm waiting at the counter a little longer than expected to be helped, which is irksome when they don't appear as busy...maybe I just need to be more aggressive, hah! Appreciate them and looking forward to coming back.
-
October 2023 by Victoria D
Great variety of tasty pizzas!
-
July 2023 by Katie Culkin
I love this place I had so much. I had left long island about 10 years ago this places is still the best after I left 10 years took my husband here and he loved it too. We walked in and I felt home and treated like I never left. Everything and everything is excellent. If you want good food and a home town feel you will get it here. Prices are great too. Thanks for making me like I'm home again.
-
July 2023 by Andrew A
I’ve been here a few times. This place is Amazing. The cases are always full with all types of pizzas no matter the time of day. Great food, Great service!!
-
July 2023 by Derek
Got 2 Buffalo chicken slices and coke for 20 bucks, the pizza was very grease undercooked and floppy chicken was terrible. Not exaggerating when I say this was the worst pizza I've had in a very long time.
-
June 2023 by Daniel H.
In my search of the best pizza on Long Island, I used to frequent Alitalia quite frequently when I lived In Manorville. I live in West Babylon now and still will make the drive to get their Spaghetti Bolognese, as they make it better than any other place I've tried. But this is about pizza. Their pizza is also pretty good. Good crisp, not overly greasy, nice sauce ! The restaurant inside, although small gives a great Italian vibe. Love this place, I drive 50 minutes now, but would drive 2-3 hours if I had to. Pizza rating is an 8.6
-
May 2023 by Ron B
Good food, good service good atmosphere and a well-established pizza restaurant. However, sometimes the air conditioning is just way too high and it’s like icebox in there. Not all the time sometimes and what happens if I eat in there then the food goes cold quickly. it’s kind of cold in there. I’d request that they kinda lower the AC a bit and it would still be comfortable in there.
-
May 2023 by Inga Veschi
The food is Delicious, and the staff very helpful and friendly.Pepperoni pizza, eggplant pizza, & plain pizza.
-
April 2023 by What's right is right
Worst customer service ever when they make multiple mistakes they blame the customer they never own up to their mistakes. The owner hates being there, and it clearly shows with the customer service. He doesn’t care if you stay or you go we were a customer for years very loyal, I had one issue spoke with the owner. He was rude obnoxious, no worries it cost me and multiple customers never to go back Just a matter of time before he sells again to get out of here. This is to the response the owner wrote “I did already talk to you THATS WHY I WROTE THE REVIEW I DID”!!! This review was well warranted!