Gift Shops near Central Islip, NY

21 locations found near Central Islip

“I posted a review yesterday which I deleted. Although I did have a problem with my order, I have to say the owner spoke with me about it and made it right. I appreciated his response and resolve. Sometimes it’s more about how things are handled than about the original issue.”

3.7 Good105 Reviews

“This company!!! My daughter has thoroughly enjoyed each item! Not to mention their customer service is honestly above and beyond!! I'm happy to support this company!”

5 Superb66 Reviews

“Best place to buy a gift. The staff is friendly and they gift wrap. They have many unique gift choices. Christine delivered great customer service. I would give more than 5 stars if Google let me.”

4.7 Superb94 Reviews

“This is a small local gift shop that has everything and anything you can possibly think of for gifting someone. The have a wide selection of jewelry, figurines, toys, frames, house wares, trinkets, and more. The staff is friendly and helpful. They also sell helium balloons for all occasions.

I will highlight that this shop has a large turnover of the items they sell; meaning that every time I visit I find new things on the shelves. The store is small, but it is packed with nicely selected items that are a pleasure to look at and buy.

They also offer a large selection of cards for all occasions. They have gifts for special occasions such as weddings, baptisms, first communions and more.

Forget Amazon, instead go to this local store to buy a special gift that will for sure be a hit.”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“The owner is a sweetheart. I looked all over for special little gifts for my daughter’s bridal shower but couldn’t find what I wanted anywhere. I came into her shop and just fell in love with so many little unique gifts. It’s great to know when I need something special this will be my go to place.”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“Always a fresh, beautiful bouquet! Delivery was on point. Thank you for once again making a special day spectacular! Your team does great work. Much gratitude from a customer in Florida.”

4.1 Good84 Reviews

“5 star nice ppl nice store. THAT said I will not return. Large women with brittle blond hair is rude. . For no reason other than it's who she is . I spend 150 a week there an will go elsewhere. A person can be many things so why not be kind.”

4.6 Superb13 Reviews

“Edible Arrangements on Commack Road is incredible. They made the most magnificent arrangement for our Staff Appreciation Luncheon today. Dolores came in extra early to make sure it was fresh and ready for me to pick up by 9am. The management/owner and staff are so lovely and a pleasure to work with. The fruit and chocolate were so beautiful and it was all gone by the end of the day. Thank you so much!”

4 Good77 Reviews

“This very quaint store has many gift items like; candles, cards, cups, costume jewelry, stuffed toys, childrens books, Hallmark itmes and cards. It is well designed and it has a nice Mom and Pop vibe.”

4.3 Superb33 Reviews

“Thank you to AVA in BABYLON, who accommodated an early delivery for my mother’s birthday on 5/23. The bouquet and balloons were beautiful. Very pleased with your professionalism and kindness. Stay awesome! ?”

3.9 Good91 Reviews

“Really well laid out place. I always find a nice little gift there while picking out a card, too. Staff is always nice and helpful to their customers. I witnessed them helping out an older couple, and they couldn't have been more patient and sweet while doing so”

4.8 Superb6 Reviews

“I visited On a Whim for the first time today. It was filled with a variety of collections for special events like weddings, babies, communions, new home, among other fun stuff like jewelry candles, kitchen , and various items. The person working helped me find the perfect sign to purchase for a house warming gift after I told her what I was there for. She was very kind. I will definitely be back again.”

5 Superb16 Reviews

“Klines is hands down the best shop in Ocean Beach. I have been spending my summers on the island for over a decade and never miss a chance to shop here. They have quality Fire Island clothing and the owner, Matt, is an awesome guy. I also take my young nephews to Klines and they love picking out clothes and toys in the kids section, I really appreciate how kind the kids are always treated by Matt and the staff. Definitely recommend you check this place out if you're in town.”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“Sooner or later people are going to realize you can't just order everything online you need to touch feel smell and see what a great tragedy it will be if we lose all of our walls I love coming here when I can it's always clean they always have what you need and what you want I hope and pray you never leave thanks for always being there.”

3.8 Good65 Reviews

“Loved this store to begin with for their Jellycat plushies, unique gifts for friends and family, and super soft pajamas! But recently on one of my Jellycat hunts, I happened to have a loose ring slide off of my finger into the pile of plushies. I didn’t feel it come off and realized at the register when looking for my wallet that it was gone. I looked all over the store and even in the plushie pile and didn’t find it! I left my information with them in case I lost it there and checked everywhere else I’d been that day with no success and assumed I must have slid it off when wiping my hands with paper towels in the bathroom and tossed it in the garbage. I called here every week and everywhere else I visited that day for about 3 or 4 weeks. I continued shopping here and checking weekly. Finally, when checking out, I asked again and the manager said to describe the ring and she said “One moment..” and I held my breath. She dug in a locked box behind the register and there it was, they found it with the Jellycat plushies 😂 She said they’d been holding it for me a few days but had lost the post-it with my contact info and were hoping I’d come back! I was so relieved as it was a gift from my mom and was impressed by the honesty of the staff to give it back to me. Thank you again so much for keeping it safe and returning it! This will continue to be my favorite retail therapy spot after local doctor visits 🤣”

3.8 Good48 Reviews

“ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!! I dealt with Alex from Lake Grove and he was incredible. So helpful and very sincerely involved with the customization and making sure you are happy with your choice. He helped me choose the right size crystal and made some adjustments to make sure it looked perfect. This was a birthday gift for my mom and he was determined to make sure it was great!! He made the 3D look amazing when I was nervous about the photo and was very passionate about what he was doing. Amazing service and so quick, only 3 days max!! Highly recommend and will definitely visit again!!”

3.7 Good21 Reviews

“This place is perfect to run in and get cards and gift supplies. They have some really nice giftables here too... And I always grab some scratch offs for my cards too.”

3.6 Good17 Reviews

“Great selection of cards and balloons.Nice gifts for all ages ranging from trading cards to cigars to Lennox figurines.Friendly owners. It's a real community store.”

3.3 Good21 Reviews

“This delivery of our large Bouquet of fruit, arrived on time, fresh, as presented. Bill the delivery driver, demonstrated his care, by informing me that no one was answering the door. He realized someone was home and waited 10 minutes to complete the delivery. The receiver was overwhelmed and so happy for the delivery.
Thank You,”

2.7 Average101 Reviews

“Hands down the nicest staff! I always order from here for local pick up or deliveries they have the freshest fruit and cleanest store location I’ve experienced. Highly recommend this location!”

2.5 Average63 Reviews

“Komal is such the most sweetest most helpful person. She took her time to explain and help me in every way possible as a first time customer . Every question was answered in the most polite manner and very respectful ; I hope this review helps her get her promotion in every way possible because she deserves it. I will be ordering again from this store in the future. Thanks again for the experience Komal”

1.8 Poor74 Reviews