Thrift Stores near Cicero, NY

15 locations found near Cicero

“This is a beautiful goodwill. It’s big and lots of stuff. The entrance/exit area is much bigger than other locations. The lights in the entrance/exit area are nice as well. One of the nicest goodwills i have been in! Store is about 21,000 square feet. Located off route 11! This goodwill is off I-81 and the easiest way is take the route 11 exit!”

3.5 Good109 Reviews

“I see a ton of people complaining about customer service it's a thrifty store how much customer service do you really need get your items pay for it and then leave so what if you have to deal with a cranky employee you really think they want to be there working at a thrifty store give them a break you're getting items 50 60 70% off stop complaining”

3.3 Good25 Reviews

“My boyfriend showed me this place and i absolutely loved it! I don’t go to Syracuse but I fell in love with it just because of this shop! I found pants that fit me (which is so hard to find) and beautiful jewelry pieces for extremely reasonable prices. Definitely check this place out!”

4.8 Superb44 Reviews

“One of my favorite thrifty shoppers, I have found absolute gems here. Their prices aren't bad considering everything has been skyrocketing. Luck in the movie/dvd section. My last visit I found the cutest little jar to be my new sugar jar and I also found some very pretty plates from the 70s. The staff was also very pleasant.”

4.4 Superb81 Reviews

“The 315 is my favorite store for used clothing. Designer brands in great shape. The staff there is always super friendly and helpful. Highly recommend a visit to this hidden gem”

4.4 Superb74 Reviews

“Fantastic thrift store with AMAZING prices! They specialize in clothing and housewares, with a few small tables and chairs mixed in. They also do lots of seasonal deals and discounts for extra savings. Today I found an adorable Columbia jacket in the 50¢ bin!”

4.9 Superb9 Reviews

“Love this little place. Always find time to swing in here and there. They run a daily special where two tag colors go on sale that day! This store has really reasonable prices; some shops prices are getting crazy...”

4.4 Superb39 Reviews

“I had to drop off a UHaul's worth of furniture and the young man working solo in the back room (on Memorial Day 2025) was very helpful, great attitude and a pleasure to meet.

If we had used Goodwill... it would of cost us nearly $600 to have them pick up. Instead a $50 UHaul and good friends had the loading job complete in under an hour.”

4.2 Good69 Reviews

“I got a Roy brown record here, good thrift store but the atmosphere isn’t great (what do you expect it’s thrift store not a luxury store, don’t go here if you demand a beutiful interior over nice people YOU PRICK)”

4.1 Good96 Reviews

“My absolute favorite store anytime I come to NY. All of my favorite clothing items are from this store!! I love the array of sizes and styles. Every time I go I always find something I love. It never fails! I highly recommend!!”

4.7 Superb29 Reviews

“Love this store my favorite in the Syracuse area it is very clean and organized. The staff is very welcoming and helpful. They also have a great selection and I always find something I like for a deal!”

4 Good57 Reviews

“All the workers are so friendly and helpful. I have never had a bad experience here. Not only that, but they have such amazing deals! Especially if you’re signed up for their rewards!”

3.7 Good204 Reviews

“This program saved my life. Many years ago they took me in and they gave me a purpose and they gave me a solid foundation and sobriety and the life based on faith. In those days it was run by a fellow that ran a tight ship and it was the best thing that ever happened to me. It wasn't easy but I came out the other side a whole year later a brand new person and I've never looked back! Thank you salvation army for all that you do”

2.3 Poor29 Reviews

“My husband and I love this Salvation Army! We always enjoy finding a good deal and good products and this Salvation Army always seems to have a good stock of items . The staff is always very friendly here at this Erie Blvd location. They have a good selection of books and dvds as well as tons of clothing.”

3.2 Average71 Reviews