Gift Shops near Cold Spring Harbor, NY

“I bought quite a few things for Christmas here and they are all beautiful unique pieces. The clothing is gorgeous and the childrens clothing is absolutely adorable and well made. The owner is an angel. She is lovely and so helpful.”

“Bill you are master extraordinaire professionally and mire importantly one of the nicest and gracious person I’ve met in my life. cristine and I always look forward to seeing your smile and of course Eric for you are always sooo pleasant.”

“Krista and staff were hired to bring their “scent bar” to my sisters bridal shower as entertainment/favors for the guests! After the shower guests were literally calling and texting raving about their perfumes and the idea itself! This was such an awesome addition to our event !”

“I visited Wit & Whim for the first time last Saturday with my little sister for a Charm making event. The store is so charming and inviting, just as Jacquelyn and her staff.

From the moment I stepped in, it was like I stepped into a different moment in time where women gathered, shared stories and remedies, crafted, and shared specially curated gifts with one another.

The store itself houses many unique items, both acquired throughout time and handcrafted.

During the event, my sister and I collectively created a bold bag charm, simple bracelet, and a reminiscent necklace. We had a lovely chat with Jacquelyn, discussing the charms and their origins, while sharing personal stories, and pouring so much of ourselves into the new pieces we're taking home.

After purchasing our items from the charm event, we had another thorough look around and of course, couldn't leave without purchasing another piece each to whisk away.

We look forward to our next visit to support your small business!”

“My go to place for any special one of a kind gifts for others and for myself! Such a warm and positive environment, and best energy from everyone who works there as well. Went to go buy a gift for my son’s girlfriend, and found the most beautiful, perfect necklace…best part was I learned that it was made by a local artist Laurie who just so happened to be working at the Hive when I purchased it! Synchronicity:) There’s something so special about meeting the artist who invested so much time and heart into something. Thank you to Laura and Laurie for bringing this cherished space to Oyster Bay.”

““I recently visited Hanalei and kula’s and it was an enchanting experience. The store exudes a delightful blend of fun and romance, creating a unique atmosphere. Their curated collection features high-end clothing from renowned designers like Magnolia Pearl and more .What sets this place apart is the owner’s personal touch – not only curating fashion but also crafting their own exquisite perfumes. This store in the heart of beautiful cold spring harbor is a treasure trove where you can discover exceptional finds. A must-visit for those who appreciate quality and distinctive style!””

“A great store. What a wonderful owner. A pure gentleman. The store has plenty of lovely merchandise. The prices are fair. A great place for your holiday needs. In addition, pop in and browse
the jewelry”

“The pharmacy has changed its name to Health Logix. Inside, you'll find a unique focus on whole-person wellness, across a wide range of curated products and services.”

“The store is great but had a horrible experience with an associate named Maria..was in the store with my mom looking around looking when we asked the associate Maria for help looking for an item she pointed and said they’re over but they are out of your price range. When we said excuse me she repeated “they are out of your price range”. It shouldn’t matter what the price range is for us we’re customers , looking to spend money and this associate made the experience horrible. Luckily the other associate was sweet and corrected her immediately but now we know we’ll just be shopping online or another location.”

“This is a small local gift shop that has everything and anything you can possibly think of for gifting someone. The have a wide selection of jewelry, figurines, toys, frames, house wares, trinkets, and more. The staff is friendly and helpful. They also sell helium balloons for all occasions.

I will highlight that this shop has a large turnover of the items they sell; meaning that every time I visit I find new things on the shelves. The store is small, but it is packed with nicely selected items that are a pleasure to look at and buy.

They also offer a large selection of cards for all occasions. They have gifts for special occasions such as weddings, baptisms, first communions and more.

Forget Amazon, instead go to this local store to buy a special gift that will for sure be a hit.”

“Lovely & wonderfully artistic displays for those who love artsy things and unique finds. Eclectic in its offerings but somewhat thematic in the cause for peace, love, and joy in the little things. Very helpful proprietor, and all the patrons seem to have the same vibe.”

“The perfect shop to get specialty gifts for yourself, friends or family. They had the most precious baby outfits. Located right in the town of Northport near the park. Friendly owner, well organized and near many restaurants to make a day trip.”

“Amazing,I needed the arrangement within an hour and had to pay cash.I got here early and everything was perfect…So happy and Iam sure my gf recovering from surgery will be as well”

“I have to be honest—after two incredibly frustrating calls with other Edible Arrangements locations, I was bracing myself for yet another letdown when I reached out to the Melville store. On Valentine’s Day morning at 11:37 AM, I placed an “hour delivery” order for a sweet surprise for my son’s pre-K teachers—something small but meaningful, especially as I’d be attending their class party later that afternoon. By the time I arrived at the school at 1:45 PM and the teachers hadn’t received anything, my heart sank. The clock was ticking, school ended at 2:30, and I had spent over $100 on what was now looking like a missed moment.

I called the original store I placed the order with—one I’d already given over $300 in business that same day—and not only were they unhelpful, they were borderline rude. No accountability, no urgency, no “let’s fix this.” Just excuses and attitude. I was told it wasn’t their responsibility, redirected to another store, and hung up more frustrated than when I started. The second location? Even worse. I was told, verbatim, “there’s no such thing as one-hour delivery on a holiday.” And when I pushed back, I was talked over, dismissed, and ultimately rushed off the phone with zero resolution. At that point, I was ready to call corporate and demand a refund across the board.

And then… I saw the email confirmation—it pointed to Edible Arrangements in Melville. Honestly? I was ready to fight.

But the moment I spoke to Erika, Brandy, Maria, and Mike, everything shifted. They were kind. They were calm. They were solutions-focused, even though this mess had nothing to do with them. Instead of deflecting blame, they said: “We’ll make it right.” And they meant it.

Not only did they track down the order, reroute it, and ensure it was delivered within 15 minutes, but they also added two extra items—on their own dime—as an apology for the delay. That kind of service is rare. And that kind of heart? Even rarer.

Let me be clear: the Melville team saved the face of two other stores that completely dropped the ball. I won’t call those stores out by name (because I’m not here to publicly drag businesses), but I will say this: I’ll never order from them again. Melville is the only Edible Arrangements I’ll ever use from this point forward.

Corporate should be thanking Erika, Brandy, Maria, and Mike—not just for protecting the brand, but for truly embodying what customer service is supposed to look like. Their professionalism, empathy, and hustle turned a disaster into a reminder that good people still exist—and they just happen to work in Melville.

To anyone placing an order: Don’t risk your money—or your special moments—on stores that can’t follow through. Go with Melville. Every time.

Thank you again to the entire team—you didn’t just deliver fruit, you delivered hope. And I’ll never forget it.”

“Dodds & Eder recently completed a patio and stone wall project at our home in Roslyn. Our experience with Tim Barry, Director of Landscape Design, and his crew was amazing. Tim is extremely creative and flexible. He listened to our wishes for the look and feel we wanted to achieve and presented a great design for our property. We appreciated that Tim always made himself available and was responsive to our many questions. The crew arrived on time and worked tirelessly each day and provided beautiful, conscientious craftsmanship. They were meticulous about cleaning up at the end of the day. We so appreciate that when our project began, the work continued each day through completion.Next up, landscaping in the spring with Dodds & Eder.Without hesitation we would recommend Dodds & Eder for projects of this type. Suffice it to say, our property has been transformed along with our enjoyment of it! Thank you so much Dodds & Eder!The Abramsons”

“One of the better Botanicas I go to on Long Island. They just don't have the fresh herbs for the Spiritual Baths. However every other ingredient can be found here. They have mats, cascarilla, candles, small charms if you're into that, Esu Aye at the door. A kind Santera (Omo Oshun) runs the place. ?? ?⚡??”

“The edible arrangements were so good I wish I took pictures.. it was for my sister’s wedding and honestly every body ate through it so quickly!!

The strawberries and bananas were so fresh and sweet the best part of it was I took some home and 2 days later they still tasted fresh!! I think this might be my go to spot. Highly recommended”

“Great selection of cards and balloons.Nice gifts for all ages ranging from trading cards to cigars to Lennox figurines.Friendly owners. It's a real community store.”

“My husband got me a dozen chocolate covered strawberries and they were absolutely delicious. Super fresh and juicy! We just moved to town and were so happy to find an edible arrangement just minutes away from us. The manager was super sweet as well! Definitely recommend ?”