-
April 2024 by Steve Schochet
Worst. Meal. Ever. We took out from the Commack Anthony’s after the amazing experience I had at one in Tampa on a work trip. My family and I ordered wings and 2 12” pies. The wings were ok but not what we remember, inconsistently cooked some just done others roasted so long the bones cracked. Fortunately for us the Pizza was awful because it made us sick all night. It looked like it was made by a 4 yr old, things just dropped on the crust, one of them had full cloves if garlic hidden under the toppings.. if I didn’t know any better I would think I was being hazed. Do yourself a favor and avoid this place, I hope for their sake the raccoons don’t get into my trash tonight.A inability to make a good pizza in NY? Management, you have a lot of work to do here. I drove past 4 amazing pizzerias to get to you…never again!!
-
April 2024 by Aziz Erdovan
Professional place.. ?
-
April 2024 by OZLEM&AZIZ
I am dasher and ubereat delivery driver part time in my side job. I picked up here order ubereat and doordash.Employees very friendly and helpful in my order pickup. I am also here customer from doordash and I used their website I registered their reward program ordering from their website.They made good pizza and place atmosphere good and employees look happy this workplace.
-
April 2024 by Monica Soberal
We were among four occupied tables. We were having a late lunch just the three of us and it took over an hour and 30 min to get our food and my husband had to take his to go because I had to go home so I could get ready for work. Either they were understaffed or they were taking care of curbside orders. I enjoy their food but next time I will order from a different location
-
March 2024 by Oliver Miller
This busser Waiter told me I’m not
-
March 2024 by katie ryan
If you’re a party of 8 or more don’t plan on coming here because the incompetent staff can’t figure out how to move two empty tables together to accommodate your “larger” party. Instead they tell you and your party you have to wait until enough people leave in order to be seated. Walked out.
-
February 2024 by Kenneth Teape
Great pizza.
-
February 2024 by Mason Wiggins
Of course the good was great, it's Anthony's! We came for the $10 pies for National Pizza Day. It was super crowder but we were seated quickly and our waiter, Jeremy, was AMAZING! He had so many tables but made sure to touch base with all of often. He was super kind and professional. We definitely enjoyed our meal/service!
-
January 2024 by Renee Cutaia
Amazing pizza and wings! Been here twice and really do love the pizza & wings. Well done pizza may sound burnt to some but it’s really not. The well done crust brings a nice amount of smokey flavor to the pizza and provides a nice crunch for texture. The pizzas are big so I would only suggest 1 for 2-3ppl. The wings are nice & meaty and I love that hey aren’t fried or bartered or coated with some oily over powering sauce. The garlic & roasted onions that the wings are tossed in is super good & brings a nice balance to the pizza carb overload. This time we also got an Alfredo pasta (for the kids) which was really just 2 stars but I won’t take it away from the restaurant. Garlic knotts are amazing too. Highly recommend to try this restaurant. Not sure if all the locations have as good a quality but I would assume so.
-
January 2024 by Angel Manuel Rivera
Excellent Bar Pizza and drink
-
December 2023 by OEF-OIF Dawgtagz
The food ( Little Paul's Meat Pizza), ambience, and our server Italia was fantastic.
-
October 2023 by MariaLana Fauth
Ordered takeout eggplant Marino side, it’s completely inedible. Every single piece of eggplant is scorched I can’t believe they served this.
-
October 2023 by Harry Handz
Don’t go there hungry. We waited 1 hours and 25 minutes for our pizza to arrive. We were a party of 4, and didn’t have anyone come to our table for 15 minutes upon walking in. Drinks took 20 minutes to arrive, appetizers another 25 mins and the food was 1 hour. 1 hour and 30 minutes for pizza was absolutely ridiculous, lost my appetite while waiting. My advice is only to if you’re not hungry, trust me, you will get hungry while you wait. The food however was good, but it is not worth the wait.
-
October 2023 by Bre-Ann O'Connell
Anthonys is by far my favorite pizza around. This place is consistent, you always know that you’re getting a perfect and delicious pizza. Not to mention their wings which are the absolute best. My family and I go here at least once a week for dinner, either to eat in or to take out. The staff is very friendly and helpful!
-
October 2023 by Lex
Me and my family go to this resteraunt all the time and usually it is great . We have the same waiters , the food is always perfect , hence why we always go back . I went there last night and super dissipated with it all. First we got handed Garlic knots that were cold in the center , we told the server he took them back and after our meals came he brought the new batch out which defeats the point of appetizers really . We understood it wasn’t his fault so we didn’t mind . Then I ordered a pizza in which it came out without anything I ordered on it ( it was just plain mozarella). I said I asked for toppings on arugula etc and the waiter apologized and brought it back and they put the toppings on and it was ok. I look at my pizza and it was 1/4 mozarella and toppings and 3/4 bread . The whole pizza even the “center “ was crust who knows how. I am attaching pictures so you can see where the confusion was paying for basically all crust . I told the waiter and he gave me 1/2 off since I ate 3 out of 8 slices which is odd as the whole pizza was the same we just were really over it at that point . Super disappointed in all with the meal and sad that we lost a place we go to weekly.
