-
December 2023 by Jerry Riter
This is a great local Bakery. There's always a nice selection of cut,-out cookies.
-
December 2023 by Sara Jones-Marks
Margaret I will always love you! You were my best friend for so many years! Miss the old days!
-
December 2023 by Kevin C.
The owners are friendly, personable people that will get to know you (and your order!) quick. They have breakfast sandwiches, a wide variety of cookies, cupcakes, and ice cream in the warmer months. They do catering with cakes and the like, as well. It's a small place with not much seating, but you don't really need it if you're on the go. My go-to is a sausage, egg & cheese with a hashbrown on a plain bagel, a diet Dr. P, and a cookie (aka the Student Special for $9-10). They also offer day-olds for $1, a real steal. Support a local Cortland business and go get some Frosted!
-
December 2023 by Jim Roach
This place is terrific! Great variety and super service!
-
October 2023 by Rich
ordered a carrot cake for a SUNY Cortland family weekend birthday. we were coming in from out of town, and hoped for the best as we were ordering a bit blind. they were not only super kind and accommodating, but the cake was exceptionally good. the frosting was super good, and the cake moist and not overly sweet. they nailed it. we will certainly go there again!
-
September 2023 by Noah Cooper
cupcakes are pretty good. the halfmoon cookie was horrendous. The frosting on it tasted and looks like when i try to make frosting from scratch and fail miserably. grocery store bought halfmoon cookies are 100x better. Hopefully they take this criticism and change whatever recipe they are using. I think the issue is too much sugar because the frosting looked a little translucent.The rugelachh , specifically the chocolate, had full unmelted chocolate chips in it. its supposed to be soft on the inside and the chocolate should be melted. I consider this a war crime from the jews in this nation. I HOPE they change their recipe. the raspberry one was fine but it wasnt great. I think they need to make a new recipe for both of them. It had crystalized sugar on the outside which is a no no (at least for me personally). The chocolate one was also quite dry. I went in the morning so its possible it was a batch from the day before. this was the morning of 9/8/2023.I hope the owner reads this review and makes some changes because they are definitely needed. personally I'm quite offended because I have very strong opinions on these staples that belong in every real bakery.
-
July 2023 by Sean P.
Reminds me of lou,s donuts a great old time donut place in cortland . Come to find out it's the family recipes! What a great selection at reasonable prices . It's a must stop when I am home .
-
June 2023 by Jennifer D.
The worst part about frosted is picking what to try! We ended up getting four cupcakes and two cookies and then splitting. I loved it all. The prices were very reasonable and the service was quick. They have coffee and tea, but it is pretty basic. I wish they had more coffeehouse style drinks to go with the sweet treats. Overall a fantastic stop!
-
June 2023 by Alex smith
Phenomenal bakery!!! Everything they make is to die for!
-
May 2023 by Saundra Brown
They even have ruggelah! They put my expensive home town bakery to shame. We got one of many things and each was great.
-
April 2023 by Deirdre S.
Not only are the bagels and cookies amazing from this place, the people that work there are great too. Service is always incredible especially from Dan, he is always so friendly and kind to all the customers so much so that he knows the regulars orders as they walk in the door. Definitely recommend, love you frosted!
-
March 2023 by Kayleigh Brown
Coming from a Long Islander who has been eating bagel egg sandwiches for almost 2 decades, I've never had a sandwich as good as the one I had from here! The bagel, the egg, the cheese, was just perfect - I'm sad I didn't discover this place earlier!
-
January 2023 by Chris Haskins
My kids love the cookie and cupcakes
-
October 2022 by Faith Sharits
I expected fresh cinnamon rolls and homemade fresh bagels but that's not what we got. Cookies were flavorless.
-
September 2022 by Jennifer Buell
Great bakery!! My friend lives down near the city and wanted to get her grandmother, who lives local, a birthday cake. I recommend them after a coworker brought me their delicious cupcakes - Frosted did a fantastic job! I've since bought so many baked goods from them ? Highly recommend!
