-
March 2024 by Rosalie H.
Excellent quality food. Exceptionally nice and helpful service people. Very healthy and delicious ready food options and desserts!
-
January 2024 by Yu P.
Wide selection of produce and premade food both hot and cold and fresh baked goods including sourdough baguettes. There is a good fresh seafood and meat selection as well. The spinach dip was meh. The guacamole was yum. The price is about 1.5x of what you will pay at a regular grocery store, but out here, this is the better choice. Worth the drive from Montauk to East Hampton to get your fridge stuff.
-
January 2024 by Louise R.
My birthday cake, the Strawberry shortcake, was spoiled, everyone agreed. In the past fifteen years or so the place has deteriorated. There are few food choices in the Hamptons ( compared to long Beach N Y.) The Tiramisu reduced its sauce and size and tripled the price. There is no more pride in what is being sold.
-
January 2024 by G A (TheFamous)
Very nice produce!I think this is the most expensive grocery store I’ve ever been to and that says something but you get what you pay for. Indeed.
-
December 2023 by Jamie B.
I would say it is expensive, but you get what you pay for. Everything is top notch quality. The breakfast bar is awesome yummy and the pizza in Southampton and Bridgehampton is always great. I've bought some nice cuts of meat and the fish market looks great and how can you resist the deserts. We get a cake there for all of our special occasions. You will spend a pretty penny but all the food is great l
-
November 2023 by Lynn K.
My Husband bought me roses for our anniversary at Citarella. Needless to say, when I opened the bouquet, one of the roses fell apart in my hands. The balance of the roses lasted 3 days. I just received the CC bill. He paid 36 dollars for almost dead flowers. I called corporate. They would not do anything for us. So with that being said, stay away from their flower department at Citerella. For those prices, for less than a dozen flowers plus the flowers were half dead, go anywhere else. (I know how to cut roses, on an angle and under water.... that was not the issue, they were old! half dead! and over priced).
-
October 2023 by Patrick Williams
Great supermarket. Fresh and inventive. Expensive.
-
September 2023 by Aquiles Brito
always good quality
-
September 2023 by Rod Taylor
Ok for a
-
August 2023 by Ola Goworek
Always fresh
-
August 2023 by Alan R.
I'm sure this is the best food in town but the place is a mOBSCENE the prices are 30 to 40% higher than the Stop & Shop right down the street. If you want to make sure you can get some great quality food this is a place for you if you're worried that you want to play a decent rate for your other purchases this is not the place. It is a mOBSCENE the food is the food is good the prices are especially high
-
August 2023 by John D'Amico
Food there is really good. Service is okay. Very busy when we went grocery
-
July 2023 by Chris H.
After a long day of yard work on my gorgeous property in EAST HAMPTON (3 acres and a 45,000 square foot estate), I rode my E-Bike to a local farmers market called "Citarella", and oh what a mistake it was. I decided to indulge in the hot bar and retrieve myself a pre-made burger. To keep it brief, it was an absolute brick of over-cooked meat that ALMOST took one of my teeth out (swear to god ). Never taking my E-Bike or scooter there ever again. God bless everyone stay safe.
-
July 2023 by Kenneth T.
They're ok... I would rather go to stop and shop just a couple of blocks over. The only real advantage is the sushi and hot food bar but nothing special about it. The prices are a big deterrent considering you can just go to stop and shop and even get organic stuff there for less than a regular run to citarella
-
July 2023 by familia gomez
Too expensive and employees first see you if you are latin keep you waiting
