-
March 2024 by Ashley Fresa
Food was ok… service was horrible. Waited over 20 minutes for drinks. Asked for a lemon to sprinkle on my steak and they refused to give me one. Have been here over a dozen times and will never go back.
-
March 2024 by MarkG441
Very cozy place. Especially nice in the darker, quieter, colder winter months Out East. Food is good, not great, and a bit overpriced. But compares favorably to most of the alternatives.
-
February 2024 by
The hamburger role was stale, very stale. The mushroom bolognese didn't seem to be made by a chef. The scoop of ice cream was laughably small. Perhaps they were missing key employees?
-
December 2023 by Joel Abrahams
The best thing I had here was the firecracker shrimp. The ribs were also great. Next time I will definitely be going to get that firecracker shrimp again!
-
November 2023 by
Our service was abysmal. Inattentive and slow. We had to go to the bar just to ask for water refills. Meanwhile, the servers were busy chatting with each other and completely ignoring the room. We saw other patrons approaching the staff with credit cards, because they couldn't get anyone's attention to bring them their checks. The food was average, with the exception of the steak frites, which was so tough that it was inedible.
-
November 2023 by
Haven't been here since before Covid, we love Vine Street too. Solid experience, always consistently good, both food and service. I'm vegan, and their options are fantastic. Not easier to find a place that does vegetarian entrees let alone vegan, with 2 excellent entree choices. We enjoy coming here in the cooler months, Very cozy interior but you don't feel cramped like you're sitting on top of the table next to you. Dog friendly which is a plus.
-
November 2023 by JudithC
We enjoy going to Cove Hollow especially in the off-season. Last night had the Prixe Fixe meals - or we thought that's what we ordered. Come time for the check and there's a $6.00 up charge for the chicken? What? Either keep it off your prixe fixe menu or put a note on the menu. $6.00 is not enough to make a stink over but in keeping with the high service that's always on display at Cove Hollow you should alert your customers to this.
-
October 2023 by momof3
Cove Hollow Tavern has a casual and very cozy atmosphere. We have enjoyed this restaurant several times during the summer. In the Fall, however, we found the food to be not as good (different chef perhaps?) and the service, while good, was a bit sloppy (wine drops all over the table). The “pumpkin” mash for example did not taste like pumpkin at all and the normally delicious apple cider ribs were just okay. In terms of value, we can't help but feel that it is simply not there. East Hampton Grill charges the same prices and has much better food and ambiance. I would recommend the restaurant with those caveats.
-
September 2023 by Juliana Amâncio
This place is wonderful, the attendants are extremely attentive and make sure that everything is perfect for your experience, I highly recommend it!
-
August 2023 by barbEH
We both ordered burgers with fries and decided to share a Little Gem Lettuce Salad to start. I thought little meant the name of the lettuce not the woefully small size of the salad for which they charged $24!
-
August 2023 by HighExpectations
Out frequent “go to” for excellent food and service! Small space with an intimate feel that translates well with their friendly and professional staff. Their early prix fixe is one of our favorites for East Hampton - you cannot beat the quality of food for the price value- even the prix fixe house wines are well chosen and a terrific value that pair well with the menu.
-
August 2023 by Susan
Great food, easy friendly atmosphere,attentive waitstaff, with a shoutout to host Gabriel and server Lucio. Firecracker shrimp is phenomenal, the chicken was terrific and the crisp for dessert outstanding. A favorite low key spot!
-
July 2023 by
It's somewhat difficult for them to seat large parties. We were 6 and were sitting at the same size table as parties of 4 - thus we were a bit crammed. Apart from that, service and food were great!
-
July 2023 by SuzanneS
I think it was an off night. Lets hope! Normally I love Cove Hollow Tavern. The burgers or the ribs are the best. But last night, we waited an hour for food and hardly got an apology. The restaurant was not fool either.
-
July 2023 by HamptonFoodCritic
They've gone downhill since last year. Smaller portions, overcooked pork chop, and overly sour bbq sauce for very dry ribs. Used to be my favorite place. Much different now. Maybe an off night?
