East Islip Carvel is very good compared to other local Carvels. The quality of the softserve ice cream is very good almost like a custard, and has not diminished over the years, like other Carvels. Would recommend.
March 2024
Limited help on Wednesdays when it is 2 for one sundaes. I left as they were slow to handle the line.Parking: Limited number of spots. Large puddles when it rains.
November 2023
Go there 2-3 xs a week. Love the people, ice cream is fresh, ample parking. Even when busy, on Wednesdays, line moves pretty fast.
