-
February 2024 by KrystalD
We went for our 18th anniversary. The food was delicious, the staff were friendly. The atmosphere was beautiful. We definitely plan to return with some friends and family. Not as expensive as I thought it was going to be.
-
February 2024 by BPdiningexperience
What a great place. I would use the phase casual elegance to describe it. The decor is modern and rustic with a touch of elegance but a casual vibe. The food was delicious and reasonably priced. Cant wait to go back in the late spring/summer and enjoy the view as well. Well done! We will be back
-
February 2024 by Natalie
The Eldred Preserve is always a great place for dinner, and while the actual dining area was not open I'm glad we experienced the lounge. It has become mine and my husband's favorite spot now, and anytime we make another reservation it will be for there, the food and mixed drinks exceeded expectations. We cannot wait to go back!
-
February 2024 by JulieK
The Old Homestead at Eldred Preserve seems to be struggling. They need to find a price point that the locals up here will agree to spend while keeping up the reputation for quality of food and excellent service the first Old Homestead built. They nailed the price but this new Old Homestead has steadily tarnished that reputation. Service was good. Orders came out wrong (husband didn't want potatoes and they were supposed to substitute with more vegetables) but was quickly fixed with smiles. Still... Bread was stale. Onion soup was good but not great. The broth missed some notes but of course the cheese did its thing so no matter what - it was good. The salad was good though very heavy with cheese. Prime Rib wasn't cooked enough for either of us. I asked for medium rare, and it came out quite rare. Husband asked for medium well, and his came out more like rare bordering on medium. Now we could have asked them to take it back (or at least mine back, and I would take his) but we just didn't want to do that. We were hungry and had already waited for the potato switch. The fact is the food was not presented the way we requested it. The roasted carrots were pretty but undercooked. They're supposed to be crunchy, but... Desserts: cake was tasteless and stale. The mousse was good. Overall - not a great dinner. Not running to go back. 
-
February 2024 by
Dining experience was extraordinary -especially thanks to the outstanding service from arrival to departure. We've been to this lovely gem in the woods since its opening and the menu and its dishes continue to evolve - reaching new heights! Each of my guests' entrees was perfectly prepared to our requested temperature and the sides were fab. My seafood special was absolutely delicious, a version of ciopinno- bravo! This restaurant just gets better!
-
February 2024 by Amandanicole17
Had an absolutely amazing evening here. The ambiance is simply beautiful, the service was excellent and the food was delicious. Will definitely be back next time we're in Eldred!
-
January 2024 by MirandaD
There wasn't one thing my husband and i didn't like. We had the shrimp cocktail, and tuna apps. A ribeye, and the special Kansas city steak, a pasta to share, sides and dessert! The panna cotta was delish! Our server Casey was fantastic. Chef Dan created a fantastic menu, and atmosphere. Will be back!
-
January 2024 by RobS
Our server Matt provided outstanding service, exceeding our expectations in every way. Regarding the food, there were some hits and misses. I chose the chicken parmigiana, while my partner opted for the ravioli. Unfortunately, the chicken parmigiana didn't quite hit the mark - it was overly dry and chewy. The sauce also left something to be desired, dominated by a strong, earthy oregano flavor that was a bit too intense for my taste. It's possible that my selection of an Italian dish in a non-Italian restaurant might have been a misstep. On a brighter note, the ambience of the place was very enjoyable. I'm open to returning and exploring other options on the menu, perhaps a steak or seafood dish next time. Also worth mentioning - the bread was delightful!
-
January 2024 by Localgal
We went during a snowstorm and were the only party that had not cancelled our reservations. Despite being the only table in the entire restaurant (there were not even any guests in the adjoining hotel), we were welcomed graciously. The food and service were excellent. We were not rushed at all. A very enjoyable experience.
-
December 2023 by BruceM
Overall, we really enjoyed. The food and ambience was amazing. The service was a bit off, but I'm chalking that up to it being New Year's Eve. We'll certainly be back.
-
December 2023 by TonyF
I've been a few times. Nice place and ambience. I tried the pork tomahawk thinking like most high end restaurants it would be tender any boy was I wrong. It was tough, dry and I couldn't eat more than a third before I gave up. Don't order that dish.
-
December 2023 by danielle cavalieri
I absolutely love this hotel and restaurant. We have been here three times now and I have yet to be disappointed. This weekend we celebrated our five year wedding anniversary and the staff did a wonderful job setting up our room with all kind of goodies. The only thing that is a negative in my eyes is the price. We just can't afford to stay in the hotel. The rooms are $500 a night sometimes more...that just doesn't work for us, especially during the winter the rooms are still $400+. That is a shame because we would definitely stay more often if the prices were lower . I not really sure why the cost is so high but it is what it is. Eldred thank you ...maybe we will stay again in another year or so.
-
December 2023 by
Truly the most magical Christmas Eve and a new tradition for us! Our server was wonderful, she was just so charming and helpful! The food, as always, was insanely delicious and creative. Just love this place. 
-
November 2023 by Maryna Ovcharenko
Fantastic dinner and great
-
November 2023 by Lauren Sorrentino
Spectacular experience that can't be explained unless you visit the location. Search it and look up the website you'll be amazed.Walkability: Breathtaking grounds.Food & drinks: Mixologists with wonderful signature cocktails and a great bar. Very interesting delicious menu.Noteworthy details: Beautiful setting with out door patios walking trails and luxury accommodations. Depending upon your budget you can experience everything or just a little bit. Happy hour Thursdays.
