-
March 2024 by Corey Benkelmann
Trivia night on Tuesday is entertaining. Legends (and their sister restaurants) have great pretzel bites and fried pierogies. The wait staff are very friendly and attentive, even on crowded nights like Tuesdays.
-
March 2024 by Matthew V
Food was kinda bland. Seemed short staffed, server was trying really hard to keep up. I wouldn't return.
-
March 2024 by Alexander Smith
You will not go hungry or disappointed. Boneless wings are super worth it, and I usually don't even like boneless. I'd bet there's 2lbs of chopped chicken breast there. Not tenders... breast. Haystack burger is great for burger lovers. Great breaded fries. Would recommend you eat here.
-
March 2024 by Tyler J.
A great restaurant, their wings are amazing, the staff is kind, and I love all the rock music they play
-
February 2024 by Brad Harbst
Got online to place an order on their website as it boasts that it now has online ordering. That's what it claims anyway, but every single time that I have ever gone to their website to place an order it says "we aren't accepting orders at the moment." And then leaves a phone number to call. Finally today I decided to do just that. I called and I let them know their website wasn't allowing me to place an order and that it never has worked for me. The woman on the other end of the phone said "oh. Interesting. What can I get for you?" I was just thinking "okay now that you've taken that complaint seriously, and reported it so that something might be done about it...." I placed my order for a pepperoni pizza and honey barbecue chicken wings. She asked me to repeat the whole thing again but in response to my chicken wings she said "regular?" And I confirmed "yes." In her mind she was thinking okay that means with bone not boneless, but in my mind I was thinking I don't want too many or too little I just want the 'regular' amount. So when I got my entire order home and I opened up the chicken wings and there were bones I almost puked. I have not been a fan of bone wings since boneless came out years ago. So this was kind of my fault but it should be a lesson that you specify what you're talking about when you ask a customer "regular?" Because you might not be on the same page as I was not. I ordered the wings because it's the only thing I'd ever had from Legends and I only ever knew about it because someone said I needed to try their wings. The wings that I ended up with were not fully covered with sauce not that it mattered because I didn't eat them anyway because I don't like wings with bones in them. The pizza is my mistake because no one ever told me if they had good pizza or not I was just winging it no pun... Their pizza was disgusting. Hands down one of the worst pizzas I've ever had in my life. The cheese wasn't melted properly and it was like all clumpy. It's hard to explain but I'll try: you ever bought a thing of bagel bites those microwavable little mini pizzas on bagels that are made to go in the microwave, and when you pull them out of the microwave them little square pieces of cheese are melted but they're not really melted together they're sort of melted separately? Like the folds of a brain? Is that making sense? That is what the cheese was like. The dough itself was soooo white, with barely any browning at all, I thought for almost certain that it was going to be half cooked dough but thankfully it was cooked all the way. I only had two slices though because it was that bad and it wasn't even coming apart well I had to use my hands to really tear the slices off of each other because it wasn't cut all the way through. Even though the person I spoke with over the telephone didn't seem interested in their website having online order form issues, the staff was still pretty nice. The price was also cheap. This is why I'm giving them three stars instead of 1. So to sum up: please always specify "with or without bones" and not just ask "regular?" And expect that slow people like myself are going to get that, and consider removing pizza from your entire menu altogether because it is not good.
-
January 2024 by James Harder
Great place for a quick bite or a few drinks to enjoy the game!! Will be back for sure!!
-
January 2024 by Beth S.
They catered our TTC year end award banquet with over 100 attendees. The set up was easy The food was amazing for the 2nd year in a row. They were easy to work with, excellent food options that were affordable. We would highly recommend them for your individual or party needs.....
-
January 2024 by The Skipper
Mac and cheese was not very good. The rest was good.
-
January 2024 by James Leister
Good food even better specials.
-
January 2024 by Tricia
Quiet hidden place that offered great food and friendly staff. Great prices too!
-
December 2023 by Lorraine D.
Sunday at 5 PM....had two orders of boneless wings TERRIBLE!!! They were either well over done, or done twice Tough, tough.... Told the waitress(who was over worked), but all we got is SORRY!!
-
December 2023 by M M
The service was great. My sweet potato waffle fries and boneless honey BBQ wings were over cooked. The wings were like tough pieces of chicken breast.
-
December 2023 by Gunnar P.
It's a pub and the inside looks like a pub. Where this place shines is the staff. They are extremely nice and work hard to make sure you enjoy your meal. The food is really good as well. Well above most of the other pubs in Elmira.
-
November 2023 by Justin Ramos
Fantastic food, personable staff, and amazing prices!!
-
November 2023 by Jen Z.
Love the staff, but food has gone down drastically lately. Chicken tenders are almost burnt not as big and fluffy as they used to be. Boneless wings are dry ,but the sauce flavor that you do get is great! And my cauliflower bites were basically batter on the inside Fries are always good luckily and the new potato cheese bites are good too. And the ranch is amazing! Legends was our go to but with the disappointment in food from their lately, most likely will try other places!
