“Fetch is such a hidden gem in Port Jeff — seriously, you’ve got to check it out! It’s not just another pet store; it’s a super thoughtful, cozy place that’s clearly built with love. Everything in there is so carefully picked out, and you can really tell how much Patty (the owner) cares about what she brings in.
I’m super picky about what I give my dog, and I was honestly blown away by how much effort goes into choosing healthy, high-quality stuff. Patty knows where everything comes from and truly believes in every product she carries. My favorite thing? The human-grade dog cookies — my dog is obsessed, and I feel great giving them to him because they’re healthy and preservative-free.
If you’re a pet parent who wants the best for your dog, Fetch is 100% worth a visit. You’ll love it!”
“Love this place! They have great quality products and my dog loves every single employee here. The girls here are so kind and extremely helpful always. This place is my go to for sure. Speaking honestly, some products can be a bit pricey but for the main products I come for (like their bulk chicken patties) well worth it! And they do offer a veterans discount for all my vets out there ❤️ I highly recommend this place ??”
“Our puppy loves the treats!!! They are so fresh and the price is right!
The staff is very helpful and very pleasant.
This is the only place we come to get her treats!”
“We have been there a couple of times since getting our new German Shepard puppy. We live the large selection of healthy foods and the knowledge of their staff. I see no reason to go anywhere else.”
“An old town favorite that has been there for generations. Very nice to have a mom & pop store with such personable people still in business. Great selection of salt & fresh water fish and more. If anything, check out their axolotl babies! So cool.”
“My sweet cavapoo Benny got a full grooming done by Hailey! He looks amazing and he feels so good to. Was done within 2 hours of drop off smelling wonderful!! I will be seeing you in a couple of months for his next groom . Thank you!!”
“I have visited First Flight Exotic Birds several times and the staff is always very personable and knowledgeable. Everything is reasonably priced and the store is always kept clean. I highly recommend this store.”
“Amazing groomers and pricing! I’ve been to many groomers and they are amazing here, my older girl has had trouble in the past she is not a fan of getting groomed and she loved it here and gave them no issues keeping her grooms low stress as she’s getting older is so important and they make that happen! Definitely continuing to use them! ?”
“I am giving them 4 1/2. Stars !!!!!!!!!! I have been in the store about 20 times since I adopted my Lab puppy in march of 23. Mostly because they have a large variety of dog products, food, bully sticks toys etc. . Their prices are a bit higher or equal to that of the chain stores. But they carry so many items in stock on their shelves it's worth it. Example! My pup is a chewer, loves bully sticks, they have them in all sizes, shapes imaginable including a three foot bully stick. You're lucky if you can find any in the big box stores without ordering on line. I mostly shop in the Selden store, and have been helped by many different employees, all of them have been extremely polite and courteous every time. Never had a problem with any of their employees. Just wanted to mention this because of all the negative reviews on their employees.”
“Super friendly & helpful staff. They were all awesome at interacting with my 2-month old puppy and they spent a lot of time showing me around the store helping me to find supplies and food for little Mushwell. Really appreciated the way they interacted with my pup and helped me out. Great place.”
“I went to SC for 9 days recently, dropped my dog at SDK. They were in constant contact with me regarding how Katie(my dog) was doing. I was very impressed by that. They reached out daily, it put me at ease. I’d definitely bring Katie back there if I go away again.”
9AM - 5PM
145 Middle Rd, Sayville
Pet Stores
“Planned to bring my 3 cats for flea baths while the exterminator was bombing out our home. The guy working was really knowledgeable and told me he couldn’t see any on them. I had used Advantage on them 3 weeks prior and didn’t know it would have been too soon for a flea bath if they had needed one. I’m glad he was honest because he said it could have been dangerous for my cats to get the bath. Who knows, other places might have not cared and done it anyway. He let me board them and the dogs while the exterminator took care of the fleas, very nice guy. He has a new customer”
“I've been searching for a good reliable groomer for over 3 years for my Labradoodle. After six different places, I was referred to Janice at South Shore Grooming. I called and left a message on Saturday and got a call back within 24hrs for a Monday appointment. I have to admit I was a little anxious, especially after having no luck with the previous groomers. I dropped off my furbaby at 10am and got a ball back by 12pm that she was ready. I was surprised to say the least since in the past it's taken at least 4+ hours at all the other places. But when I got there I was pleasantly surprised. Janice was able to accomplish what no other groomer had, she managed to do a full grooming on my relatively big (75+ lbs) girl, without having to air dry her or keep her in a kennel for longer than needed. Keke (my furbaby) was absolutely excited to see me but what I noticed was that she didn't look sad like she normally did after our previous grooming sessions. Janice took real good care of Keke and you could visibly see how happy she was. I feel like I just hit the jackpot finding Janice so close by. Thank you for taking such good care of my furbaby and making her look and smell great!!! I can officially say I have found a groomers for LIFE!!!!! If you need a reliable, fast and courteous groomer look no further than South Shore Grooming for all your needs, you will not regret it!”
“Good pet store but has an "out of order" sign on the bathroom door for 2 years now. Ridiculous that they can't provide a bathroom for customers like every other pet store.”
“I have to be honest, when looking for a rehab I skipped this one because of the low stars. The one we picked was awful. I had to pull my father out. a friend then recommended Island. When I first walked in, it was 10pm. I noticed how absolutely clean the facility was. The staff was welcoming. They made my father feel so welcomed. Everyone is so nice. They communicate every aspect of my fathers care. The physical therapists are great. The bathrooms are clean and stocked. My father is a picky eater and they do not stop trying different food so that he eats. the nurses are awesome. I can't say enough how great they all are. Not one issue. The staff answers quickly to the call button. They make sure my father is comfortable. If you are looking for a rehab for a loved one, I strongly recommend Island.”
“This store is great! I shop for cat food, treats and supplies. They usually have a fairly large selection of brands. The store is clean and the employees are pleasant & helpful. I cannot comment on the grooming- that’s the only reason I didn’t give 5 stars.”
“I love frequenting this store. The staff is friendly, helpful, and take a lot of care with the animals that they're selling. I love them all. The store is clean, well organized, and welcoming.”
“For a chain store, this one outshines most others. Always clean and well stocked with personable people. They also have a dog trainer (Jade) that is full of knowledge and great to work with. There always seems to be a sale going on as well. I am big into aquariums and this store does not disappoint.”
10:30AM - 7PM
152 Medford Ave, Patchogue
Pet Stores
“I had a great experience here today. I came in with my daughter who is turning 3 in a few days. She’s been asking for a pet bunny for her birthday and after unsuccessfully checking chain stores in the area, I realized that this place was in our town and only a couple miles from our house. I didn’t know what to expect going in but had a wonderful experience. It’s much bigger of a store than I thought it would be and the staff were all extremely friendly and welcoming of a toddler coming in without a stroller. I held my daughter at first as we acclimated and then put her down when we got to the bunnies. All of the staff members who came by us were smiling and in great spirits with good customer service. Once I told someone we were interested in buying a bunny, a female customer service rep helped me and my daughter by giving us all of the information I need to know about bringing home a bunny and she was incredibly patient in letting my little girl pet the available bunnies and decide which she wanted. She was extremely knowledgeable about the bunnies and their policies and procedures for buying one. We made our deposit at the front desk with another rep who was great. We are so excited to pick up our new bunny in a few days and am so glad to know of this gem right by our house!”
11AM - 7PM
1177 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island
Pet Stores
“My collie was groomed there today first time visit. Lauren did a beautiful job and she smells wonderful. I will definitely come back and share the great news. Thank you.?”
“In a world where it’s all about money & business, this store is an exemption. Giving 10 stars for the owner who took his time to show us around & gave us a neon tetra glow fish for free to “start us on the right track” Prices compared to Petco & Petsmart are waaay cheaper. And the variety of fishes there is in the store was a plus! We will definitely be back for future needs.”
“I love this location, everyone is always so friendly. I also feel like the individuals that I've spoken to about pet care really know what they are talking about. They have done a great job in updating many of the care brochures over the years.
I still believe Petsmart as a whole should really evaluating the methods in which some of these animals are obtained. Responsible breeding is one thing, but there are still too many people who are not doing right by the animals. They need to be sure they are not supporting anyone like that.”
“I spent time speaking with the store manager in the aquatics dept. He seemed very dedicated in his position and I intend to come back for a couple Otocinclus Catfish and some other critters I wanted to add to my planted aquarium. Thank you!”
9AM - 9PM
401 Sunrise Hwy, Patchogue
Pet Stores
“Our puppy Maxwell just completed his 4 private training lessons with Victoria H. She was TERRIFIC! Our puppy just loved her and would listen to her. She taught my husbnd and I how to follow through with the training at home and it works!!
We highly recommend Victoria for anyone looking for an excellent dog trainer!”
“Excellent customer service, same day shipping. Prices are the best. I found the exact same can of fish food flakes that my pet store was charging me $9 for and here it was $2.95. Great place to get all of your pet supplies.”
10AM - 12:30PM 1:30 - 5PM
1100 Middle Country Rd, Selden
Pet Stores
“i just bought a tarantula here today and i had such a great experience! a very nice and funny lady, jackie helped me and she was so kind. she helped me get everything i needed and even recommended me many things. she helped me get a vet & helped me choose which food. & she did a spectacular job taking out the tarantula for me which can be very scary her and sam were great workers and they deserve a raise! thank you so much”
“I’ve been a customer with Farmingville Feed for approximately 6 months. I use them to get my mini-dachshund groomed every few months. I have always been comfortable with each grooming session, and have always been pleased with how my pup looks. Laurie is friendly, attentive, and always handles my dog with care. Laurie’s grooming is always done efficiently, and my pup looks adorable and smells amazing every time! Overall, I would highly recommend Farmingville Feed to anyone in need of a professional pet grooming service that is reliable and top-notch!”