Toy Stores near Farmingville, NY

14 locations found near Farmingville

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 2280 North Ocean Avenue Suite C, Farmingville NY 11738

    3.8 Good 47 reviews

    “Amazing staff, they are so nice and sweet the managers Nick and Spencer try to accommodate as much as possible and really make the store a welcome place for kids and adults. Even when some of the customers are rude and nasty the staff stay calm and don't engage. I watched a customer scream at the employees for no reason at all and the staff literally said im sorry youre having a hard day. When the person walked out I said how did you stay so calm and the employee said I think its just the heat or she must be having a bad day. You can't make somone fake being that compassionate they just are really good people dealing with a lot of difficult situations with poise and character.”

  2. Broadway, Broadway Broadway, Rocky Point NY 11778

    5 Superb 67 reviews

    “Tony was very pleasant and professional to work with. He did a fantastic job on the haircut and he was very patient with my child. You can just tell that he has a heart of gold and he's very good at his mastery of barbering. I highly recommend him to everyone”

  3. 31 E Main St, Patchogue NY 11772

    4.8 Superb 24 reviews

    “I had the most amazing experience shopping for my daughter‘s baptism dress. The two women that work there were unbelievable, so amazing to work with. I truly couldn’t have asked for a better experience. If I could give them more stars as I would.!!”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 518 Smith Haven Mall Spc 08B, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.6 Superb 51 reviews

    “The workers here are very kind especially the worker that was here yesterday at the pokemon learning center (not sure what it’s called lol), but he was education the kids about it and was giving away free pokemon lego stickers and a pokemon pikachu crown, it was so adorable and cute!”

  6. 4747 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station NY 11776

    4.8 Superb 19 reviews

    “Please shop local and support this incredible store! Recently I stopped by The Learning Tower to purchase birthday gifts for my 5 and 7 year old nieces. The two extremely knowledgeable women working helped me choose the perfect games for my shy niece. These games help with reading, thinking and promote speaking to other players. It’s so nice to walk into a store where the staff knows the product, makes really good recommendations, and are able to answer all of my questions.”

  7. 66 W Main St, Sayville NY 11782

    4.6 Superb 32 reviews

    “We love this adorable store! My girls and I are always popping in, My girls love buying the stuffed animals and the slime. They always have the cutest items.The staff is amazing and we’re so happy to have such a great children’s store in our town!”

  8. 2860 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.5 Superb 68 reviews

    “This place is awesome! So many nostalgic toys and memorabilia, and I even got a rare funko for someone's birthday! Affordable prices on anime figures and always something new to discover!”

  9. 787 Middle Country Rd #17C, Selden NY 11784

    4.6 Superb 14 reviews

    “THE BEST FIVE BELOW AROUND!!!! STAFF IS THE BEST NEVER EVER NASTY ! I CAN CALL ALL DAY EVERYDAY AND THEY ALWAYS ANSWER THE PHONE ALWAYS HONEST HELPFUL NEVER MEAN ! SHOUTOUT TO MIKE AND I FORGOT HER NAME BUT SHE ANSWERS ALMOST EVERY MORNING SHES SO SWEET !”

  10. 2860 Middle Country Road, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.4 Superb 65 reviews

    “This place seems to have some pretty good stuff in comparison to other antique/collectible store. The only thing that I find odd is the store is reselling an unusual amount of new wave transformers for 50% MSRP. While there is a Target and Walmart nearby.”

  11. 540 Smith Haven Mall Spc D05B, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4.4 Superb 63 reviews

    “Thank you to the entire staff that was working today! I had my daughter’s birthday party here and the experience was 10/10! We had a huge group of kids and everyone had the best time ! ❤❤❤ highly recommend !!! You all are amazing and made my daughter’s birthday beyond memorable !”

  12. 235 Middle Country Rd, Selden NY 11784

    4 Good 45 reviews

    “Amazing store owned by some amazing people! I used to work not too far from this location and I really loved coming here. I wish I had more time to come out. This place is worth going out of your way to visit!”

  13. 130 New Moriches Rd A, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4 Good 43 reviews

    “I visit the five below in lake Grove frequently and have never had an issue the staff is always friendly the store is always clean. Today(10/24/26) I stopped in to make a return around 5pm and the two employees working were absolutely incredible, I was blown away! I really wish I took the time to ask them their names because they were fantastic and deserve to be recognized. Not only were they both incredibly polite, and very helpful to me and everyone else shopping but they were constantly working (reorganizing shelves, assisting customers with self check out, helping with pick up orders) and going out of their way to offer extra assistance to everyone in the store! Its incredibly rare to see this level of customer service these days and these two were absolute stars!! I really hope five below management reads these reviews and acknowledges them both.”

  14. 901 Boulevard East, Yaphank NY 11980

    4.1 Good 147 reviews

    “I was just at this location on 7/15/26 at 7:05pm and Tony dispensed my order at curbside pick-up. I was in slot #6. He was kind, thoughtful, and very helpful. I really appreciate his kindness.”

  15. 113a Main Street, Stony Brook NY 11790

    2.8 Average 37 reviews

    “What an amazing children’s store. Cottontail’s of Stony Brook has beautiful children’s clothing from newborn and up, unique toys, books and fun gifts and so much more. I walked around and couldn’t take it all in and I know I didn’t see everything. For a relatively small store, they have such a great selection. I was looking for a gift and changed my mind three times because I couldn’t stop looking at the next thing. I settled on swim trunks with a swim shirt and a teething ring. I was pleasantly surprised that they gift wrap too. I made my purchase. The two women who worked there were very pleasant, offered assistance, but allowed me to browse without any interruption. This is a cute find and I know I’ll be back there soon.”

Advertisement

Toy Stores in nearby cities