-
July 2023 by Google user
We had a pizza logs for an appetizer, club sandwich and sweet potato fries, plus a bison burger and fries. EVERYTHING WAS FANTASTIC! Will definitely be stopping to eat there again. Great service, hot food, lots to look at on the walls!
-
June 2023 by Stephen G.
Great food Fantastic ambience Great destination location. We always bring out of town guests here. Mature and friendly wait staff. Food and prices good.
-
June 2023 by Brady S.
Excellent food, great service, cozy environment, great place to eat at. We came from out of town and had an excellent time there
-
June 2023 by Benjamin C.
Stopped by on a quick trip to Salamanca on a Friday afternoon, stopping in around 5 pm. There were several vehicles in the parking lot, always a good sign at rural restaurants in my experience. We sat at the bar and were immediately waited upon getting our drinks quickly. They had your standard bar selection, just what you'd expect with Southern Tier beer on tap. The interior has a quirky outdoorsy atmosphere, there are antique guns everywhere on the walls. Cool animal mounts are abundant, highlights include: jackalopes, a warthog, and possibly the largest taxidermy squirrel I've ever seen. The bar top was also clean, no crumbs or sticky spots.The menu had a good variety of offerings: maybe 15 apps, steaks, burgers, sandwiches, soups and salads. The people I was with were raving about the clam chowder soup. So I had to try it, i love soups and get them with almost any meal. They had about 5 specials written on a board by the door. The French Onion Prime Rib caught my eye. It can be a risk, but I've had some of the best prime rib in places like this. Our soups came out quickly and it was pretty good clam chowder. It's a thicker chowder and very creamy with nice chunks of potato and a decent amount of clams. Served with a package of oyster crackers, I added a little black pepper and housed the bowl. The side salad from the prime rib came out almost at the same time. It's a side salad that comes with a big chunk of beef, let's be honest it's not why you're ordering the meal, but it was fresh and their Italian dressing was above average. You're not just getting Wishbone in a cup.The star of the show was the French Onion prime rib. I order mashed potatoes and gravy as my potato, they came in a small crock with the steak. I ordered it medium rare and it came with a generous amount of caramelized onions and melted cheese that was broiled to a light golden brown. The steak came out a little closer to medium than medium rare, probably a byproduct of melting the cheese, but it was delicious none the less. The beef was tender and the flavor combination was awesome. The mashed potatoes and gravy were good, nothing to get excited about but provided a nice compliment to the prime rib. The Horseshoe Inn was a great experience: quick service, good food, and an interesting atmosphere. It wasn't super busy when we were there with maybe 4 other parties in the restaurant. I'll definitely be back the next time I'm in the area, maybe try the wings and French onion soup next time.
-
March 2023 by Carol Puleo
Love the decor. Great taxidermy pieces. Excellent fast service. Drinks were great! Will have dinner here again.
-
March 2023 by Geno Juart
Just a great place. Hidden in the Allegheny mountains of New York. With outstanding food
-
December 2022 by Ronda Whitford
My first time here... Enjoyed a nice warm meal with my husband when we went for an impromptu drive and found ourselves at this restaurant/bar. They were pretty busy, but staff did their best for good service.
-
December 2022 by Jon B.
Love this place. Great atmosphere good food all around solid joint! Foods nothing fancy but the price is right and the taste is great
-
December 2022 by Kimberly Rexford
Good food! Many choices on their menu. A bit of a drive but worth it.
-
October 2022 by bill14729
You can't go wrong eating here food is good rest rooms are clean and a good place to meet with friends to have a drink.
-
October 2022 by Jordan
If i could put zero stars I would. I am a person of color \\u0026 I have never felt more disrespected in my life. I go out for dinner with my god family \\u0026 get served the coldest rawest steak of my life when I ordered a medium well queen rib eye. And when I bring up how poorly it was made with a server, I get laughed at about the quality of the steak. New staff or a cook needs to be hired because theirs no way I should’ve left that place feeling as awful as I do now.
-
October 2022 by Mark Kurtis
Absolutely an astounding establishment. If you are a hunting / fishing sports enthusiast, you need to go here. Food is good and service was friendly. Priced right.
-
September 2022 by Janette Coyle
Food has gotten to very small.portions. where once it was a great place to dine...been there approx 6 times, but doubt I'll go back.
-
September 2022 by Steven Worthington
Went out to dinner with several friends over Labor Day weekend. This restaurant is remote but the food is outstanding. The restaurant setting is very casual and the people are friendly. You will encounter everyone from business owners to a group of bikers out for a ride dining here. If eating out is about the food for you...make the trip!
-
August 2022 by Chatkat4
Visiting family and we all went here last night for dinner. The restaurant is not enormous, but can comfortably accommodate larger parties, small parties, as well as bar seating. It is very rustic, which definitely appealed to my hunter husband! The walls are lined with wildlife mountings, vintage guns, antique farmhouse items and pictures. They had some great specials but we all ordered from the menu. Hubs had broiled seafood platter, I had broccoli Alfredo with shrimp, other family members had the fish fry, and spinach ravioli. We all thoroughly enjoyed every bite, with enuf that some had to-go boxes. Just loved watching the many hummingbirds visiting the feeders outside our window. Staff is so sweet, attentive, and personable. It was just a lovely time and meal!
