-
February 2024 by Dulce Rivera
Excellent Service, super attentive and received best possible help with questions on items that were sold. Would definitely recommend.
-
February 2024 by Heather Smiler
Joe was very friendly and professional. He explained how the price was determined. I was paid a fair price for my sterling silver.
-
February 2024 by Jennie Theoharis
I should have been treated more fairly as I have been a customer for several years. I should have been given the correct amount for my St. Gaudins $20 gold coins instead of hearing about what you can sell them for and what your profit would be. I’ve never been told this before. I have usually gotten the correct amount.
-
January 2024 by Dominic Ortiz
Went to Eastern sell a collection of Lionel Trains.Had them from the 1950’s and 60’s For me it was a little sad , letting them go (childhood memories with Dad etc)What was so positive was working with Carmine ,the train guy.He made me feel very comfortable for my choice coming to Eastern Numismatics. Was able to get top dollar for my collectionExtremely knowledgeable ,with no drama during our transaction. Carmine is your “Guy”Would highly recommend and you would do a disservice to yourself to go anywhere else.
-
January 2024 by Andrew McAuliffe
I met Anthony for an appraisal and he was a wonderful professional to deal with. Would absolutely recommend him and this business.
-
January 2024 by Herb Rifkin
I had dealt with Anthony and was quite pleased. Wound up selling them some coins and felt he was very fair in his evaluation. I definitely will recommend him and the company.
-
January 2024 by d whalen
Very detailed analysis of the items I had to sell
-
December 2023 by Aidan K
Evaluated some coins I brought in within minutes, appreciated the honesty and insight they gave me on the items I brought in. If you ever stumble upon collector's items or have your own would definitely recommend bringing them here
-
November 2023 by pasquale maiolo
The staff at Eastern Numismatics Inc. are true experts in their field, and their passion for numismatics is evident in the depth of knowledge they bring to every interaction. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a novice enthusiast, they take the time to understand your needs and guide you with expert advice. I was particularly impressed by their willingness to share insights and educate me about the coins I was interested in, making the entire process not only smooth but also incredibly informative.
-
November 2023 by Tommy Karate
I called these People a while ago to get a price to sell my piece and i spoke to some gavone that gave me the spot on silver . I explained to this moron that the the piece was PCGS certified and what the piece was and he ended up knowing nothing and hung up on me . I went to another coin company and paid me on the spot for what the piece was worth. What a bunch of bozos .
-
August 2023 by Joanna
I few months ago I was looking for a place that would swap a ½ oz gold bullion that I had for some silver bullion.I Googled ‘Coin Dealers on Long Island’ & couple came up. I had gone into to two other places out on the island that were advertising to be Coin dealers. One was a Jewelry store in Amityville & the other in Melville. The owner of the Melville location came across as a shyster, he knew everything & I shouldn’t trust anyone (except him). He offered me less than the Spot rate to sell the Gold Piece & added a premium fee to the spot rate of the silver, he wanted to sell me. I was looking for Rounds & he was pushing bars – that was all he had at the time. I had an uneasy feeling, so I left.Then I stumbled upon this Gem of a store. I came here last, because it advertised as a kind of Antique store, named Eastern Numismatics.I called first & spoke to Joe Parrella / President. He was very friendly & told me to come in. He sat down & spoke to me about why I wanted to swap the gold for silver. He explained what kind of silver he had on hand – mostly small bars & that he had rounds on-order & should have them in a few weeks. There was No pressure to sell the Gold & buy the silver that he had… just information.While I was waiting for him to come out I was looking around his many show cases of Jewelry. If you love Jewelry – this is a place for you! There were so many beautiful pieces. I spotted a bracelet that looked like one that I had lost & decided that I would come back for it.A month or two later, I needed some extra cash & decided to sell the Gold Coin that I had. I went back to Eastern Numismatics, asked for Joe & told him what I needed.He looked up the pricing, showed me where he was getting it from (I already knew the current Spot rate) & offered me the SPOT RATE – not less like the other store did.While we were talking, I mentioned the bracelet that I was looking at & saw that it was still there. I happened to be wearing a bracelet that looked like it that looked like it – but was much lighter in weight.He took the bracelet out of the case for me & I tried it on. It was a little tighter then I would normally wear, but wearable. I was considering taking it anyway. He actually talked me out of it. Saying that I already had one that looked like it, so why would I settle for one that was smaller than I would normally wear? I was selling the gold coin because I needed the extra cash, so I should just take the money & use it for what I needed & come back another time & maybe find something nicer? ~ I agreed.He immediately wrote me a check & I was on my way. All the way home I was thinking how nice & Fair he was & how I was going to be a customer in the future.I am writing this because I wanted others to know, that you can trust Joe Parrella & his team !Oh, one more thing.. There is a very Negative Review above stating they are Rude, the shelves are Empty & Poor customer service. I STRONGLY disagree and wonder if they were in the same place that I was in.I had a totally different experience … on 2 occasions!Thank you Joe & Eastern Numismatics! I hope to be back to buy some jewelry sometime soon. ?
-
July 2023 by Cameron Johnson
Excellent customer service. Would recommend anytime you are looking for jewelry! Made me feel like at home instantly when I walked in. I will for sure be back
-
June 2023 by Bill McAmis
I have been collecting coins for years on my own with moderate success. A couple of years ago I happen to connect with Tony McCall of Eastern Numismatis and my success rate sky rocketed! Tony is is a gem in the numismatic arena, he is able to locate hard to find coins at reasonable prices. If he is not working for you, he should be!
-
June 2023 by Mark E Washburn
Eastern Numismatical is very knowledgeable about model-trains, and happy to share that know-how with me. Their selection of trains is vast, and i also bought rare coins from them. Very happy with finding this hidden gem of a store in Garden City. ENI, you rock! (And, yes, thanks for reminding me about Mothers Day. I’ll be back to buy those cameo earrings for my wife.)
-
May 2023 by V Lamberty
I had a fantastic experience with Eastern Numismatics Inc. Tony McCall provided impressive, cutting edge, expertise and job knowledge. He created several great options to put me over the top. He looks out for his clients' well being. My experience was top notch and straight forward. I highly recommend Tony McCall and this company!
