-
March 2024 by Robert Dutchen
Noah's has a great reputation but I was pretty disappointed with the burger. The calamari app was nice and flavorful, but the burger was bland, and not even that hot. For $30 it was very underwhelming. Fries also tasted frozen. I'd rather go to Shack Shake any day of the week.
-
March 2024 by Louise L.
We were very disappointed with the Kobe beef burger that we had the other night. Especially since Noah's is our favorite restaurant on the North Fork with, I feel, delicious and consistently good food. First, the burger wasn't hot (or charred enough), the cold slab of tomato on top cooled the temperature even more and the bun wasn't warm let alone toasted. All this made for a non-pleasurable experience. The fries were industrial so we couldn't even enjoy them. Really, Shake Shack burgers are better! I do remember having had a decent burger at Noah's a few years ago. It seems the kitchen staff should be retrained to turn out burgers the way they should be done.
-
March 2024 by ChrissyK
This is one of the best restaurants in the village of Greenport. Consistently good food and good service. I've never had a bad experience here. I would highly recommend trying it.
-
February 2024 by MarP
We had such an amazing time at Noah's this weekend. Our waitress brought over two glasses of champagne to celebrate our anniversary right when we arrived. We remain very touched by this! Thank you for a wonderful evening.
-
February 2024 by Neb1937
We and our friend are elderly - the food and service were exceptional. We would like to commend the young lady who served us (did not catch her name) as absolutely outstanding from start to the finish - carling, attentive, amusing and simply a lovely person. Please pass our appreciation to her - Reservation at 6pm - Brashich. You should be proud of her. Neboysha R Brashich
-
February 2024 by Kris Hulse
Food was good just remember to ask for salt and pepper, foods were in need.
-
January 2024 by Anne Howard
It's always a pleasure to be at noahs!
-
January 2024 by Janice F
Excellent menu with thoughtful ingredients. Also a few good vegan choices. Lovely atmosphere right across the waterfront park.
-
January 2024 by LindaM
We choose Noah's apps, small plates, & sides to share, to maximize a “tasting menu” experience. Recently, shared by 2 people: Hummus/pita, roasted beets, sautéed spinach, pot stickers, & sirloin sliders, a couple glasses of wine each, followed by a shared Key Lime pie. It was plenty of food and delivered a delicious, delightful experience! However it's not cheap...$195 including tip. The service has always been excellent, and the large room is trendy/minimalist with comfortable space between tables.
-
December 2023 by Melissa M.
All around great food, service, and ambiance and one of my favorite restaurants I went to while visiting greenport. I loved that so many of the ingredients came from local farms and were simple dishes but done very well. Will definitely be back.
-
December 2023 by Natalie M.
Came here for appetizers and drinks however, was so disappointed by our cocktails and service that we left without eating. I ordered a dirty martini made with tanqueray and what i received was a glass of olive juice with lemon. The martini was so salty it tasted like a cold cup of the long island sound after a storm. I was truly taken aback so i asked the bartender what happened and they insisted that i asked for lemon in it which was odd. It was completely opaque super salty and oddly sour with the lemon. Just a really odd experience overall. The ambiance was lovely though and i'll definitely update this if i ever go back because their menu does sound good and i would like to try it!
-
December 2023 by Clayton S.
Noah's is always great. Great food and service, and Im always at home there. A great place near the inn . Walkable . The guests love it too
-
December 2023 by ESS177
This was a pleasant place for dinner, but the food was not as inspiring as we had hoped. We had a reservation and were seated right away, but we waited almost 10 minutes for anyone to take a drinks order - we had to flag a bus person down and ask them to get our waitress. Once we ordered though, things came fairly promptly, and the waitress was lovely. The cauliflower appetizer was surprisingly not crisp, which is the whole point of the "buffalo" style dish, though it was tasty. The roasted delicata squash was pleasant, if a bit boring after the first few bites. Fish and chips were ok, and much better once I requested malt vinegar to go with it - the french fries seemed to be made of composed rather than fresh potatoes, which was surprising at these prices. The crab cakes were just average. Very nice wine for $75/bottle.
-
November 2023 by Chiara C.
The seafood was bland and very poorly cooked. The fish in the fish and chips was slimy and probably not fresh. The fried calamari portion was incredibly small and half of it was fried fennel. The lobster roll was bland. The coca cola is soda stream cola for 4$.
-
November 2023 by gailp3
The food & service was great but ambiance was definitely lacking. Had the Crab Cake, Calamari & Barata with Beets. All delicious! Come for the food but romantic vibe not so much!
