Supermarkets in Hampton Bays, NY

52 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays NY 11946

4.4 Superb 66 reviews

• Today 7AM – 11PM
• (631) 728-6759

“Went to the grocery store. It was the first store I entered whose prices seemed to be online normal . The staff were friendly and helpful. The only thing I found unacceptable was a soft rye bread that was hard as a rock. Everything else was nice and fresh.”

252-14 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays NY 11946

4.2 Good 106 reviews

• Today 8AM – 9PM
• (631) 723-3071

“(Please click on photo to see Wild by Nature at night). I have been shopping here almost daily since the day they opened. That's when I stopped visiting their East Setauket store, as this branch is much more convenient. The food is delicious. The store, including bathroom, is very clean. Cheaper conventional, as well as organic items, are available. It's great not having to read labels as much.....I trust them more than other stores for safe food. Everything is Non-GMO, for example, while elsewhere, buyer beware! The staff is terrific, all except one short, rude woman, and the deli offers fabulous dishes! Yes, this place is definitely expensive, but you won't find super-long checkout lines! The wide array of products and healthful foods make it worthwhile for me to shop here. Nutritious food is "preventative medicine".....eat right and stay out of trouble! I'm worth it. You're worth it.”

52 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays NY 11946

4 Good 188 reviews

• Today 7AM – 11PM
• (631) 728-6759

“i have been shopping at the hampton bays king kullen for close to 20 years. And although i will often shop at other grocery stores closer to where i live i have found the hampton bays king kullen overall provides the best service from the very courteous, helpful and smart and friendly knowledgeable staff most of whom have been there for as long as i’ve been going to the excellent quality of their produce and meat department. i give them 5 stars easily.”

39 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays NY 11946

3.8 Good 81 reviews

• Today Open 24 hours
• (631) 594-5366

“Walked in & was immediately drawn to all the colors of the fresh produce. It’s a wonderful place for vegetables & other food items. And I love their bakery. They make the most delicious big cookies on the left side of the checkout counters. They are so good dunked in tea or coffee. I don’t know the name of them but they should be named Delicious. It’s a great addition to Hampton Bays.”

194 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays NY 11946

3.7 Good 137 reviews

• Today 6AM – 10PM
• (631) 728-2020

“As someone who shops here for personal and small business needs, I’m very impressed with this location. I can see the staff work hard to keep everything organized and clean as best as possible. As a local I noticed the influx of people when another grocery store closed and this S&S has adapted well and made necessary changes. Glad to see a lot of variety, especially the free-from options. Thank you and keep it up!”