“The best butcher shop I have ever been to. Their products are pricey, but the quality is out of this world. I stop by as much as I can and I am never disappointed. If your looking an old-world butcher experience, definitely stop by.”
“Amazing first experience the owner Lou is an absolute sweetheart and knows his stuff! The meat is top quality and fresh and the store is super clean. Prices are reasonable and worth it for the quality of meat and service you get. I’m a customer for life now and will not go anywhere else. Best butcher on Long Island hands down!!!”
9AM - 6PM
210 Main St, Farmingdale
Meat Shops
“Excellent Steaks, Pork,, Chicken etc!!!! This is my go to place for meat orders. Have ordered from them for a while now and they deliver to Westchester County, NY. Always top notch quality and delivery guys are great. Highly recommend them. You will not be disappointed.”
“Very well organized store you will never see anything missing of selfsame, meat section is always clean , I never had a issue with meat quality even though I am extremely picky on meat quality”
10AM - 5PM
276 Cuba Hill Rd, Huntington
Meat Shops
“Not only the best eggs and fresh organic produce, but having all the animals out front is a fantastic treat for the little ones. The mini pies are perfect as well (apples crumb!)”
“The people that work here could not be any nicer or more helpful. I came here because I was given a gift card for Christmas. I have honestly not been to a butcher/ meat store like this before and had no idea what to order or how to order. The person that helped me gave me suggestions, toldMe his favorite, how to cook it, and then wrapped them so I could cook some and freeze some. After following his directions I will say the NY Strip I cooked was PERFECT and one of the best pieces of meat I've ever had. I will definitely be back next time I need to get a high quality piece of meat!”
“Bayville Meats is the best!! Their sandwiches are the best I’ve had on Long Island, their prepared food is delicious and of course the quality of meat is excellent!! They also have a wide range of grass fed options which is nice to have. The store team is always so pleasant, we love the meat center!”
“High-quality products with friendly staff. Also carry odds and ends such as french fries and seasonings. Old-school type of service - asked for a product, they didn't have it and they recommended another place I could get it. Not often that a store will do it.”
“There is no other place like this!! They only have the highest quality products. Keri, Anthony and their family are the kindest and we always have a great experience here.”
“I have been going to Mathews Meats for probably 20 years. Moved from the neighborhood 3.5 years ago to Nassau and still go back. A family run business. The nicest people to deal with. If you don't see it ask! If you have a question....Ask! They will go out of their way to help you. Best Greek foods without having to go to Astoria! And the souvlaki's are to die for. Highly recommend.”
“Very friendly and helpful. Everything looks delicious. We went right before Easter last year. There was a very long line. But they had their sales people on top of it. They made the line move fast. I will be going back again. Did I tell you everything is delicious?”
“I like this store for their meats and premade meats, also a great deli!Only downside is I don't love their limited selection of shelved grocery items, but for certain things, they're great!”
“WONDERFUL"butchers". Do not need to buy Big boxes of items. Meaning, you can buy smaller quantities that will last . The butchers are artists who cut/slice your purchase as requested. The Deli guy is fabulous. He knows his art. Helped me make the best! Philly cheese steak ever!! Clean!! No slippery floors. Fresh fruit & vegetables. Always.Helpful staff. Courteous. The managers are super. Do not forget the cashier staff. They are beyond great and genuinely niceNorthport is my store”
“One of Long Islands best kept secrets. Torn between telling you how much I love this market and keeping quiet so it doesn’t get too crowded.
Here’s some helpful hints. Bring cash and be in the mood for meat and fish. Once again, no credit cards, no grocery shopping. Cash. Steak. Chicken. Fish.”
“The staff at the North Babylon store is always very helpful and friendly. I placed a catering order with them for the holidays and the food was delicious, like it always is. This is my fifth or sixth catering order with them and they never disappoint.”
“Clean store, spices in alphabetical order, help is available either you looking for an item or a recipe, fresh Halal Meat and also variety of marinated yummy meat items.Pots and Karahee etc, frozen kabob, samosas, Paratha, mithaee.....All you need.”
“I would say I would definitely ranked Joe's meat market 5 star service is excellent the butcher is excellent the deli is excellent vegetables are always fresh They are always polite and very professional”
“Food ain,t just food. And it hasn't been for many years. The small business proprietors of healthy foods are not getting rich. In a time when quality food is at a premium, C&C exemplifies the best of what is possible when it comes to clean natural meats. My family and friends can taste (and feel) the difference. Thank you C&C.”