-
April 2024 by Casey Angelo
This has been an island park staple for many years! Always best seafood around! No matter how crowded they are, their customer service is amazing and on top!
-
March 2024 by Lisa Anderson
First time here. Combination platter delicious. Huge portions! Fresh seafood. Clean. Great manager Pepe who manages a friendly staff. Definitely coming back.Bill and LisaBayside NY
-
March 2024 by Margie Fiorillo
Daughter treated me for breakfast and lunch. Had doctors appointment didn't eat due to had to fast. My waitress Alexis was very respectful and nice.
-
March 2024 by Veronika K.
Food is good. Not every dish is my favorite, so what ever I order was tasty. :) I love their red clams chowder soup! It's delicious! I prefer to go there only summer time since you can seat outside and enjoy bay view! Service is good also. Had a few cocktails which were tasty also. I will stop by for sure again
-
March 2024 by vladimir stekolchik
Very fresh seafood. Oysters and mussels was very fresh. Macaroni and cheese with pieces of lobster was delicious. Definitely be
-
March 2024 by JK Ames
The best "seafood shack on a highway with a view of an abandoned landfill" in the world. Probably.
-
March 2024 by Ricky A.
Food OK- service poor to OK . On the water a plus. I've been there 3 times and never impressed. The servers were lacking in proper training.
-
March 2024 by Theresa Kenion
Freshest
-
March 2024 by Greg M
The seafood was very fresh and the service was outstanding.
-
March 2024 by Dawna Hyatt
For all the money o spent the crab tasted old and I caught
-
March 2024 by Pat Caffrey
Overall the food was excellent. The ship po boy was really good. The shrimp were plentiful, fresh, and very tasty. The fries were some of the best I've had in a while. Service was really
-
March 2024 by NANETTE TURNER
My husband and I frequent Peter's. Their food is delicious and prices are right! We had a gift card so we went to the restaurant side. My husband loves fish and got the crab pot. I had stead with delicious veggies and roasted potatoes. Enough to take home!
-
February 2024 by BAK1
Solid seafood meal at Peter's. We usually eat in the casual, self-serve side of the restaurant and hadn't been at the full-serve restaurant in years. Three in the group ate broiled fish, one ate flounder oreganato. Two had soup, two shared fried calamari. Food was very good. Key lime pie for dessert was just okay.
-
February 2024 by Molly Martin
We ordered five meals for takeout and were blown away by the portion size and quality of the food. The mussels with red sauce appetizer fed all of us and then had some for left overs.Amazing spot.
-
February 2024 by Anders B.
What here on a cold day in February after a run to Costco. Their lunch special is incredible. A number of sandwiches for $15 and it includes a drink, even a beer if you like. I'm sure the atmosphere is incredible during the summer and I will definitely be back.
