Toy Stores near Islip Terrace, NY

21 locations found near Islip Terrace
View Map

“Best comic shop on long Island in my opinion. Jason is the owner is awesome A legitimate comic store - tons of keys CGC slabs, magic cards, Pokémon cards, toys, funko, statues. Magic the gathering game night on Sunday's. Can't go wrong in here -- I highly recommend”

4.9 Superb14 Reviews

“Cute little toy store for younger kids...my son (he's five) enjoyed picking out a toy for himself. I'd rather give my money to a small business over a big box store!”

5 Superb32 Reviews

“Cool store. They had most Gundams you'd find on a site like newtype which was surprising that the selection was that good. Store has so much cool stuff in it tho. Literally so much...”

4.9 Superb38 Reviews

“Took my daughter brother and nephews today to Blast From the Past. First time there, wonderful experience great prices. Met Paul and Rich who made us all feel like family. 5 stars!!!!!”

4.7 Superb50 Reviews

“This place is real cool if you are looking to collect going back in time. The people there awesome. Won't be disappointed. Anywhere from diecast cars to comics to wrestling sports. Mention Ray sent you”

4.8 Superb30 Reviews

“Great Antique store. There is different vendors inside with tons of Antiques and Collectibles, with toys and household things. Prices vary. But a kool place to get a few things or just browse.”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“The service-knowledgeable staff-professionalism are far superior to my many journeys in life. There are no commercial distractions i.e.television screens. They have pursed there path in life which is dedicated to it's customers”

4.6 Superb51 Reviews

“This store might be smaller than the ones in the city though it always carries the latest sets not just for the lunar new year. It has Star Wars, Marvel and Harry Potter sets to name a few.It also has sets that cater to younger children (ex: duplo) and sets for older children (ex: friends or city toys).Employees are always welcoming and helpful. Legos are not cheap though sometimes you can find sales if you look.”

4.8 Superb22 Reviews

“A wonderful cute little store for toys and comics and collectibles. Was happy I got an batman 89 comic and McFarlane Superman rebirth! A nice town to shop in and take a visit in too.”

4.4 Superb72 Reviews

“Went here with my boyfriend for a date. We had such an amazing experience. I made him a shark and he made me an eevee. The process is so easy and fun. The staff are super friendly and helpful. Always love going here <3”

4.4 Superb49 Reviews

“I've been to this place. Few times and they have change it around. I do like it better this way, considering when I first started coming they barely had baby clothes. Now, when you enter in, it's toys/clothes and other items for toddlers and teens, which they update every now and again which I like. When you walk into the back, where they had classes for kids to do fun activities, it's all items for babies. Which I absolutely love that they did this. I'm not sure if they still do the activities for the kids though.”

4.7 Superb9 Reviews

“Really cool store. In addition to the great selection of cards and gift wrapping options, they have lots of unique items. I still like the idea of holding something in my hand and deciding to purchase. I've made my girlfriend cry with happiness a few times with items I have purchased at this store. 4 out of 5 stars because the people at the register are not exactly outgoing or friendly.”

4.3 Superb35 Reviews

“Very impressed with the operation. Would like very much to be a part of the process of supplying people with their products. I think it's an important function in a child's learning process and development.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Ordered a toy online fast secure shipping Great Commcation a toy I had been looking for and was very happy to find in very good condition will definitely buy from again”

4.3 Superb25 Reviews

“Store is beautiful and has the most unique and adorable baby and children’s clothing and gifts. Staff is friendly, welcoming and helpful. They also offer adorable birthday parties which are so much fun!!! I Highly recommend.”

4.1 Good8 Reviews

“On October 20, 2023 Five Below had their grand opening in Selden. The same parking lot as Shoprite and the Post Office. You can find a large array of stuff. However, not much I have a use for. Today was my second time I went to check out the Christmas items but again I was not impressed. What I noticed is the presence of many tweens and teens looking for a bargain. Most items are less then $5. The youngins were grooving to the music while enjoying their shopping experience. Five Below has a decent inventory of tee shirts & other clothing, beauty products, party goods, holiday decorations, gifts, arts & crafts, toys, games, books , candy, cell phone accessories and so on and so on. Although I don't see myself purchasing much here I would definitely consider getting a few gift cards and gift bags. It was nice to see the young population shopping comfortable for things they can afford and connecting with their friends. Best wishes Five Below, I wish you much success.!”

4 Good2 Reviews

“This is a fun place, always something unique to buy, great deals and you find alot of stuff you didnt know you wanted, great candy selection, and they keep the place well stocked and very clean, items for any scenario, household, plants, electronics, school, food, they have it all.”

4 Good16 Reviews

“This store is great with a wide selection of games and apparel. Not only that but the staff here are very helpful and really try and make an effort to assist you with any questions.”

3.9 Good25 Reviews

“Long story short: I just received a UPS package from Tara Toy Corp. I had no idea what it was, but my wife explained she contacted Tara Toy Corp about a toy our children received for Christmas that was malfunctioning. Come to find out, it had been about a decade since this toy was discontinued ?. No big deal, my wife said, thank you and goodbye! BUT their customer service rep went above and beyond. They really didn't have to send us that package but it was a really nice/kind gesture. Thank you!”

3.8 Good22 Reviews