Jewelry Stores near Islip, NY

30 locations found near Islip
View Map

“Diana & the Mazza team are knowlwdgeable & professional ... and always make you feel welcome ! Have been going there for years and always walk out very satisified with service and product ...”

3.7 Good3 Reviews

“Just had the best experience on a whim! I've been meaning to sell some gold, and found The Gold Source right around the block. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted right away. LaKisha and Stanley took extra care in assessing my jewelry (which I loved). Both owners really light up a room- I am VERY happy the price. If you've been waiting on selling some jewelry, I can honestly say this is the best place to go for the best price you'll get. Thank you so much :)”

4.9 Superb63 Reviews

“Devin's is that friendly neighbor establishment that you can always count on I've have had jewelry repaired and purchased as well They are fairly priced. Customer service nowadays is a lost art. Not at Devins.”

5 Superb36 Reviews

“A great find. Brought in 3 watches I thought were hopeless and Ricky had them up-and-running in an hour. Great pricing. And a shop filled with top brand jewelry & watches. Definitely be back.”

4.8 Superb82 Reviews

“Trish was so nice & so helpful. She helped me design a beautiful ring. I was married 50 years & had my engagement ring reset.It came out amazing❣️Definitely would recommend this place❣️”

4.9 Superb39 Reviews

“I bought a beautiful diamond ring that in the end was custom made. I spent quite a while there and the staff was so kind and patient through the whole process. I highly recommend Squires!”

4.9 Superb36 Reviews

“Serg is amazing! He doesn't take advantage and truly understands his customers and their needs. He fixed a bunch of watches for me at a reasonable cost and restored my Michele watch to BRAND NEW status!!! I am so happy to find this jeweler in the neighborhood!!!”

4.8 Superb58 Reviews

“This store has some really cute pieces and I love how friendly the staff is. Jen and Olivia were a wonderful help to me while shopping with my kids! My daughters also managed to find a little cute tea set! We’ll be back!”

4.8 Superb41 Reviews

“Such a beautiful store! So many unique things, great for finding gifts. And the Christmas store! You have a fantastic buyer who has elegant taste. Such fun doing my Christmas shopping!”

4.8 Superb35 Reviews

“I was nervous because sometimes buyers aren't flexible and trustworthy but my experience with Collectors coins and jewelry was great. Staff was Professional, fair and friendly definitely would do business again.”

5 Superb17 Reviews

“My fiancé and I wanted to look around for wedding bands, we didn’t expect to leave with rings for each of us! Steve and Amanda were very helpful and took their time helping us find the perfect rings with a great price.”

4.8 Superb30 Reviews

“I would highly recommend D'ore jewelry shop. My fiancé and I had such a pleasurable experience dealing with Danny and the girls over there. Danny was super friendly and knowledgeable and made this whole process easy as could be and created the ring of my dreams!”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“Great Antique store. There is different vendors inside with tons of Antiques and Collectibles, with toys and household things. Prices vary. But a kool place to get a few things or just browse.”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“The cutest store ever! The owner Joe is the absolute best. He customized embroidered sweatshirts for me for a gift that I needed for that night and when there was a small mistake in the embroidery, he remade them the next day and shipped them all for free. Awesome customer service! Such a great addition to babylon. The tea at their tea cafe is also fantastic.”

4.8 Superb24 Reviews

“Exceptional Service from Andrea and Sal at Kay Jewelers!We recently had the pleasure of shopping at Kay Jewelers and were delighted by the outstanding service provided by Andrea and Sal! Their knowledge, professionalism, and genuine enthusiasm for helping me and my fiancé find the perfect engagement ring made our experience truly memorable.Thank you once again for the wonderful experience.Alex and Tetiana”

4.7 Superb25 Reviews

“Banter Jewelry has a variety of jewelry. Gold and silver. I have bought several pieces of jewelry from them. You can purchase warranty on jewelry which I do recommend. A lot of there prices are delicate.”

4.7 Superb24 Reviews

“This is the only place to get your newest summer outfits. The owners are super friendly and make every customer feel welcome, and look great. The styles are one of a kind that you won’t find everywhere else out there or on the main land, and they get new looks in all the time. I especially love all the accessories and beach-ready gear like coolers, bags, sandals, sunglasses and towels. I get compliments all the time on items I pick up from the store. The store also does an excellent job of making it an “experience” shopping there, with fun music, air conditioning!, and accessible changing rooms. The employees are all very patient and want you to be happy with everything you pick out, and they make intelligent suggestions, not just pushing anything. Also, when a few tweens/teenagers were acting like the place was their own private hangout, the staff politely had them move along. Overall, this is a place you have to visit and pick something up, and everyone you know will compliment you on your new items!”

4.6 Superb37 Reviews

“Incredible service from Hersel and Dan. It's not every day that you find a place that has beautiful jewelry and their level of customer service. I've been a customer for over 10 years and highly recommend them!”

4.8 Superb14 Reviews

“Awesome antique market with many unusual finds, right here in Oakdale. It's the largest antique center on Long Island and has tons of interesting clothes, books, toys and furniture, etc. It's so much fun to spend an hour or two just walking around and looking at all the really cool vintage items. The prices are reasonable, so, go check it out and enjoy!”

4.6 Superb31 Reviews

“Maui and the rest of the staff were very helpful. He made two different necklaces for me custom made and they came out better than I could of asked for. Only place I will go for jewelry hands down !! Thank you”

4.7 Superb18 Reviews

“I have been in the store several times and my experience was nothing but great with friendly and very helpful staff. I am going to return because I had seen things in a catalog that I would like to buy and wanted to see if they carry it in the store. I rather give them my business. Regarding to the one review, mask wearing, at that time it didn't matter if a person was vaccinated or not, mask wearing was a requirement by the CDC to enter any store. The stores needed to comply by the CDC covid-19 policy. Yes, it was an inconvenience. Yes, many of us hated it, but you want or need to go shopping you needed to wear a mask, CDC policy for the state of New York. It wasn't just at this store it was everywhere, stores, banks, a person's job and etc. Any place that was enclosed and had people. It was a very difficult time for us all, very difficult. Therefore the store should not be held responsible for following the CDC policy, they had to. I am eager to go back.”

4.8 Superb13 Reviews

“Exceptional Experience at Jared Jewelers, Lake Grove, NYI recently had the pleasure of visiting Jared Jewelers in Lake Grove, New York, and I must say, the experience was nothing short of extraordinary. My fiancé and I were on the lookout for a unique wedding ring that would stand as an enduring emblem of our love, and we were not disappointed.Our consultant, Gloria, was a key highlight of our visit. Her customer service skills were outstanding, and her knowledge of the craft was impressively vast. Gloria was genuinely interested in our vision and worked tirelessly to help us bring it to life. She was patient, answered all our questions and shared invaluable advice that guided us through the process.The result of her dedication was a custom-made wedding ring that took our breath away. It is, without a doubt, the most beautiful piece of jewelry we have ever seen. Every detail was meticulously crafted, and you could see the love and effort that went into its creation. This ring is not just a piece of jewelry, but a work of art that we will cherish forever.Our experience at Jared Jewelers was beyond satisfactory. We are immensely grateful to Gloria for her exceptional service and for helping us create a symbol of our love that we will treasure for a lifetime. We highly recommend Jared Jewelers in Lake Grove, New York, for anyone in search of high-quality, custom-made jewelry. Their professionalism, quality of work, and dedication to customer satisfaction are truly commendable.”

4.5 Superb62 Reviews

“I came in to have a wristband size adjusted for 1 watch and a battery replaced on another watch. The young lady who assisted me did a great job. And the service was completed quickly,”

4.5 Superb43 Reviews

“Excellent teachers in a laid-back atmosphere, that encourages creativity and the development of enhanced skills in both Stainglass and Mosaic work. An absolutely wonderful owner run art experience. One of the few remaining on all of Long Island. I drive out from Long Beach, New York regularly to do my work there and to obtain materials.”

4.8 Superb10 Reviews

“The owner is a sweetheart. I looked all over for special little gifts for my daughter’s bridal shower but couldn’t find what I wanted anywhere. I came into her shop and just fell in love with so many little unique gifts. It’s great to know when I need something special this will be my go to place.”

4.9 Superb8 Reviews

“The best of the best. I've been getting my hair cut by Alexa for a few years now. I always get a great cut and conversation.Services: Shampoo & conditioning”

5 Superb5 Reviews

“Super helpful staff, with a great attitude.Gave out good advice, asking questions I had not thought of.Prices seem too high on gold items, but silver prices seemed fair.”

4.6 Superb12 Reviews

“Amazing selection of fun clothing! Friendly service and they are never pushy. The prices are amazingly reasonable and everything is well made. The jewelry and accessory selection is also very nice. If you are looking for clothes that are stylish, comfortable and well made try them.”

4.4 Superb42 Reviews

“My experience with Argyle Jewelers was nothing short of amazing. Joe and his staff were extremely knowledgeable and helped guide me in the right direction. I was stuck on a certain style and ring specification, and I must say they truly delivered. I told them what I was looking for, and the very next day they had it in store for me. They did this with no guarantee that I would purchase this diamond from them nor did they ever attempt to make me feel I had to. It was an extremely comfortable process and I felt like I was being helped by family. Thank you so much for an amazing ring.”

4.5 Superb14 Reviews