Jewelry Stores near Islip, NY

29 locations found near Islip

“Mazza Jewelry is truly one of a kind. My husband purchased my engagement ring from Mazza and we also bought our wedding bands here. They made every experience so wonderful and so fun. They have a wide selection of beautiful rings and can design engagement rings to be exactly what you imagine. Thank you to all the amazing staff and owner, Diana! We love you guys and are so happy you all are a part of our special memories ♥️”

4.6 Superb28 Reviews

“Ricky is the best. He exceeded all expectations. I had gone to him looking for an engagement ring, and described everything that I was looking for. He has a great inventory in store that he was able to show me similar options, confirm everything that I wanted, and offer great advice and recommendations. He is not pushy at all, gave me a clear timeline of how long it would take for drawings and delivery of the custom ring, along with an extremely reasonable price and told me to take as much time as I need, shop around, and comeback if I want to purchase it. There was no questions, I bought it that same day. The drawings were sent to me for approval and I was able to talk with him on the phone to ask questions about the design and make any changes if I wanted to. The ring was finished even earlier than he originally said, and it is absolutely beautiful. The ring is everything i wanted and more and my fiancé couldn’t be happier. I have since gone back to Ricky for other Jewelry and will continue to use him in the future. 10/10.”

4.9 Superb288 Reviews

“This place is fantastic.(first booth on the l.eft). I had many items repaired. Manuel was so helpful and patient with me. John had repaired all items, I couldn’t even see where he repaired the hinge on my bracelet. This is now , my new go to place and the verity of jewelry is nice! Thank you fellas!!!!”

5 Superb98 Reviews

“I love the creativity of this shop - there is always something different to browse through! I pop in every single time I’m in town and am never disappointed. The staff is always helpful and delightful - make it a priority to stop in!”

5 Superb109 Reviews

“We recently had a problem with my Wife’s engagement ring. After some discussion Maria the manager came through with a full shank replacement at no cost. I will continue to do business there and would highly recommend this store to anyone. Great customer service”

4.8 Superb332 Reviews

“I’ve had consistent positive experiences with Devin Jewelers over the years, from jewelry purchases to resetting my wedding band and repairs. Danny is a true perfectionist and always makes sure every detail is absolutely perfect. Andrew is incredibly kind and helpful, and the sales associates are always warm, knowledgeable, and attentive. Their craftsmanship, customer service, and attention to detail are truly exceptional. Highly recommend!”

4.9 Superb133 Reviews

“Beautiful selection and an incredibly helpful staff! I’m so happy with the purchase I made for my husband. They even cleaned my ring while we were checking out, which was such a thoughtful touch. Wonderful customer service—I highly recommend them!”

4.9 Superb150 Reviews

“Marcos was extremely pleasant, knowledgeable, and helpful with my mom’s and my experience. Did a fantastic job piercing my ears and I am extremely satisfied with my experience.”

4.9 Superb103 Reviews

“NO WORDS! Mark just made the most fantastic wedding band for my ten year anniversary. He was able to take diamonds from my grandmas rings and recreate the most magical wedding band that I get to wear forever!! I will definitely be returning with more jewelry and more visions for him to design.”

4.9 Superb123 Reviews

“Always a great experience at this Deer park location. And to make your experience even better ask for Mariana V. The absolute best and she will treat you like family. We purchased my wife's engagement ring from her. With Mariana's experience and guidance, my wife absolutely love her ring. Thank you Mariana.”

4.8 Superb150 Reviews

“Savannah is amazing! I came to see her after she is now the Manager in Bayshore, I have been a customer of hers since 2022. She always goes above and beyond. I wouldn’t want to be help by anyone else. Best customer service super efficient and an absolute sweetheart. Come see Savannah for all of your jewelry needs1”

4.8 Superb117 Reviews

“I recently had the pleasure of dealing with the collectives Coins, jewelry and watches and specifically regarding the Firearms portion of the business. I wanted to say it was a great experience. I mean the folks were real real nice. I even had my my dog with me and they treated my dog like royalty. It was. It was very nice nice Folks great business already dealt with them twice and will be doing it again. Awesome Folks thank you thanks, Mike.!!!”

4.8 Superb92 Reviews

“I have bought many pieces of jewelry from here and have always been very pleased! I have to say that Paul is amazing and helped repair a necklace twice that I bought elsewhere. He did it right on the spot and charged me the bare minimum! He’s amazing and I will definitely be back!”

4.7 Superb121 Reviews

“I did a piercing with Tahsin and she made me feel very comfortable. She did it perfectly and was very patient and kind. I have not had any trouble with pain as I usually do, she did a great job! I will definitely be referring her to everyone. ?”

4.8 Superb55 Reviews

“My mom and I love coming to this shop! There are so many interesting and unique pieces. We’ve spent hours there just looking through the different items, and are always finding something neat! Some are decently priced while others seem higher in comparison to similar pieces from other vintage shops.”

4.7 Superb153 Reviews

“Had a great experience at New York Gold & Diamond. The whole process was easy, transparent, and I felt like I could trust them every step of the way. They made everything simple and stress-free. Highly recommend!”

4.8 Superb51 Reviews

“A very Magical shop. Lots of Beautiful pieces and meaningful stones and gems. Jewelry from head to toe. Excellent prices too.
Excellent and very knowledgeable customer service. Rose knows everything about every stone. She loves the entire shop,and she can answer any questions you may have. You can tell that she enjoys every aspect of helping you out in what you might not know. It's her pleasure to help you understand.”

4.7 Superb82 Reviews

“Adorable place with great service and selection! My daughter found her flower girl dress there and they made the whole experience so special! Reasonably priced gorgeous dresses available for all ages ✨️”

5 Superb59 Reviews

“This establishment is an absolute pleasure to do business with. Everyone there is friendly, courteous and professional. Their goods and services are high quality and priced fairly. Maria has been taking care of our transactions lately, and she is the best! So glad we discovered this little gem of a jewelry store!”

4.7 Superb94 Reviews

“The owner was very transparent and awesome to work with, he helped meet all the things I was looking for and even gave some options and opened my eyes to more of what I was looking for very impressed with them, so grateful for the outcome and customer service!!”

4.8 Superb54 Reviews

“Customer service is quite responsive and attentive to customers; the order was completed on time. Serge was very friendly and kept his promise.
A very beautiful pendant arrived in lovely packaging.”

4.7 Superb91 Reviews

“I came into look at engagement rings and met Rhonda who helped me through the entire experience. She was very kind and helpful while I looked at different options. And I think we found my ring.”

4.6 Superb116 Reviews

“Been coming here for 30 plus years. My family and everyone there's no place else that I go. Bobby and his family are amazing.You would only be shorting yourself if you went somewhere else”

4.8 Superb68 Reviews

“Best place to buy a gift. The staff is friendly and they gift wrap. They have many unique gift choices. Christine delivered great customer service. I would give more than 5 stars if Google let me.”

4.7 Superb94 Reviews

“Best Jewelry Store in long island. Trustworthy, Affordable, Fair, and prompt. Great quality gold and 5 star repair services. Stan is personable, understanding, and always willing to work together. Highly Recommended!!”

4.8 Superb53 Reviews

“All I can say is that this place is the absolute best!

I was diagnosed with breast cancer last year and Alexa has been my go to ever since. She was the only one I could think of to shave my hair after receiving my first Chemo. She made me feel at ease, supported, and safe. She has a genuine authenticity and a beautiful soul. It’s not just about hair with her, she wants to make sure her clients are happy!”

5 Superb40 Reviews

“First time visiting yesterday and I’m hooked! The clothing selection is amazing—perfectly balancing comfort with a chic, dressed-up look. The staff is wonderful, especially Danielle. She can navigate the store with her eyes closed and immediately found exactly what I needed.”

4.7 Superb66 Reviews

“Came in K jewelers For a gift
with the help of the exceptional staff member ZARIA I was in and out With the perfect gift. Her calmness and expertise was greatly appreciated. If I ever need to go back, I will absolutely request the staff member. Her customer service skills were exceptional Very professional at what she does. Ty”

4.6 Superb70 Reviews

“I had a great experience with Ethan Jordan Jewelers. Management was very friendly and accommodating. They had the best selection of Jewelry that I was looking for. Customer service was excellent. I went to every other jewelry store around and I highly recommend these guys over the big names.”

4.5 Superb86 Reviews