-
March 2024 by Lutz Finger
Coffee is not what you want to drink here...
-
March 2024 by J J
Great coffee! Thank you!
-
March 2024 by Kristen P
I cannot thank Ithaca Bakery enough for helping me deliver cupcakes on my son's birthday. Unfortunately, I had originally ordered with Rashida Sawyer Bakery weeks before and 48 hours before his birthday, Rashida Bakery called to say they do not deliver on Sundays. Their only suggestion was delivering the cupcakes on Saturday, which was not my son's birthday and not what we had agreed to. I immediately called Ithaca Bakery and they agreed to custom make 2 dozen pumpkin cupcakes (for the price I was paying for 1 dozen at Rashida Sawyer bakery) and deliver them on Sunday (which was less than 48 hours away). Ithaca Bakery has a kind staff, delicious cupcakes, and I am so grateful that they were able to provide cupcakes to my son on his birthday when his family could not be there to celebrate with him. Ithaca Bakery is a local business I will continue to support and share with the rest of my son's school community.
-
February 2024 by Rob Collins
If presentation and reputation were the major contributing factors, it would have a higher rating. It reminds me of a higher class version of Sopranos in Waverly, only 10 times cleaner. Unfortunately, they seem a bit understaffed, and perhaps because it was the late afternoon, their donuts were nothing to write home about.
-
February 2024 by Tommy Deredita
The guy at the counter taking your order definitely makes you feel rushed and kind of sassy . Sandwich was really good, but woah for a 5in long sub, my wallet thought it was 5ft long. Very very very expensive to eat here. Everything is small here but with a huge price tag. Come on, IB!! It's
-
February 2024 by Aislyn Berg
yummy and they gave me a little discount because i was crying :)
-
February 2024 by German Lopez
Over price
-
February 2024 by Andrea KF
The review below mines saddens me to read. I loved the bakery for its diversity in food/drinks and all types of other stuff in there. Coffee wasnt what i ordered but i had already left and it was too late. There is a rude guy and pretty sure I know who the woman in the review about the guy yelling at her is talking about. All I can say is thank God it wasn't me because i wouldn't have gotten to taste this beautiful sandwich they made. (When I deal with rudeness I don't support) . My food was amazing and glad I made the drive here to check this place out !
-
February 2024 by Sierra Robinson
Worst customer service!! Within my order I ordered two bagels toasted with cream cheese. I am thankful I ate them in house because when I opened them they were over toasted with almost no cream cheese. The worst part is when I kindly notified them a staff member never looked at them and literally yelled at me across the entire store in front of a line of customers, "You need to order extra if that's what you want!" I was shocked. See my photo below. I had to take this photo and make her look at it. They never apologized for the poor product or the even worse treatment. Nor did they offer to replace it. $45 worth of products later and total disrespectful mistreatment I can't imagine returning again or recommending this place.
-
January 2024 by Will Doherty
You're a darned fool if you don't try the rosemary and salt bagels here at least once in your life. A darned fool, I say.
-
January 2024 by Mary Mantelli
Great food, good coffee, warm, friendly service.
-
January 2024 by murat oktem
I don’t recommend their sandwiches and hash browns. Tried twice and had twice stomach burn.
-
January 2024 by Luis sponza
Variety and prices.
-
January 2024 by T
Poor setup, order location varies, they won't cash you out, have to go to another line/mess. Then 5 min of nonsense waiting (all I wanted was 1 toasted bagel) was able to pay after they REQUIRE your PHONE # TO WAIT for a TEXT when your order is ready. By now 20 min has passed since I placed the order 3 counters ago , and on my way out my name was shouted. Turned to receive it , said 'thanks' and the woman who finally gave to me responded "Gee thanks for the bad attitude! Hope your day goes the same!". I chuckled at the idea, I was already going to be late for work. When I got in my car, my phone went off, informing me my order was ready to be picked up. No kidding
-
December 2023 by Patrick Keough
Great sandwiches, friendly
