-
February 2024 by Ariel Tello
I wish we took more photos. The fried artichoke was quite possibly the best thing I’ve ever eaten in my life. I am a vegetarian and I ordered the special which was like a mushroom wellington. Oh my gosh, my taste buds didn’t know they were going to experience such delicious food.What a great find! We were from out of town, but holy moly please go here if you live around in the area. You will not be disappointed. The house made bread was also so delicious!It blew us out of the water. Thank you for the excellent food and service!
-
December 2023 by John Buzon
So much yum. Always has amazing food. Specials rotate all the time. Very cozy, our go-to for date nights.
-
November 2023 by Brian Cohen
While staying in Grand Gorge our daughter recommended Mill Pond for dinner. We couldn’t have been more pleased. The atmosphere, the service and graciousness of the host were amazing. We were equally pleased with the menu as everything we ordered was delicious. And as an extra bonus, the live music that night was a real treat. Next time we are up there we will definitely be back.
-
November 2023 by Christina Brizzee
The wait staff was fantastic. The food was amazing. So full of flavor and the presentation wow. The restaurant itself was a beautiful setting and very inviting. Can’t wait to go again.
-
October 2023 by H Drummer123
Overpriced, very very slow service ?♂️You should wait minimum 40 min.Rude owner??!!!!!Quality of food really bad ? ? ?Last time I tried burger, meat was smells, taste bad (not fresh).My wife ordered fish, was not fresh, not salty , taste like trash ( terrible).Highly not recommended!!!!Never will come back!!!!!
-
October 2023 by Kate Horan
Thank you for a lovely stay at MIll Pond Inn. The room was lovely, and it was immaculately clean with beautiful, high end linens and amenities. The Inn is charming, in a gorgeous location with a view over the pond. David provides 5-star service with local provisions for a delicious continental breakfast. This place is very good value for the overall experience. I will certainly return.
-
October 2023 by Mirit Rose Jackson
I usually try to only leave good reviews but it really frustrated me when I called in an order and specifically stated that the dish I am ordering is oily. Therefore, it should not be packaged in a paper container. The young lady agreed said she would do her best. when I picked up the order, sure enough it was in a paper to go container and a paper bag. Before I even reached my vehicle It had leaked and the paper containers were saturated in oil - I couldn’t even put it in my car and I had no time to go back - what a waste !Extremely disappointed
-
October 2023 by Michael Francisco-McGuire
We had a really good meal. We decided to sit in the bar, which has much more of a cozy atmosphere than the high ceiling-ed main dining area. The steak was great. Holy moly, the artichokes were out of this world. We’ll certainly be back for special occasions.
-
October 2023 by Meaghan Brennan
We had a number of our guests stay here for our wedding weekend and everyone absolutely loved it! We also hosted our brunch there on Sunday and the food was out of this world. We can't wait to celebrate anniversaries at the Mill Pond for years to come.
-
August 2023 by mary russ
We ate dinner there-did not stay over. The food was very good. Service was excellent. We sat outside overlooking the large pond-very pretty!!Food & drinks: Great salad and truffle fries! Burger done perfectly.
-
August 2023 by Deanna R.
Beautiful inside and out. I really liked this place. Food and service were great. Can't wait to try something else next time
-
August 2023 by Kaiden Wolf
This is a must have place to go to eat. We went there on Wednesday which is pizza night from 5-8pm and the pizza was made fresh from the outdoor pizza oven. I got the margarita pizza which was awesome. Also there is a pond in the back with tons of seating options inside and outside (even one in front of the pond)! There is also a little trail that’s like 2 minutes starting across a bridge to go to the other side of the pond which there is a bench to sit! Overall, amazing place and food highly recommended.
-
August 2023 by Teresa Tribble
Very comfortable and clean. Food was outstanding. Service amazing. Very quiet and rural. Would recommend to those who want to escape to big city life for a few days.
-
August 2023 by Roselyn Lachapelle
We sat on deck overlooking the pond, the views and atmosphere were great. The service was fantastic, every meal delicious and the wine was superb. I would definitely come back.
-
August 2023 by Loz Tunnicliffe
Beautiful property. Well appointed rooms. Surprisingly luxe for the Catskills. David (owner) is a lovely guy also. Would stay again!
