Variety Stores near Lake Grove, NY

12 locations found near Lake Grove

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 130 New Moriches Rd A, Lake Grove NY 11755

    4 Good 43 reviews

    “I visit the five below in lake Grove frequently and have never had an issue the staff is always friendly the store is always clean. Today(10/24/26) I stopped in to make a return around 5pm and the two employees working were absolutely incredible, I was blown away! I really wish I took the time to ask them their names because they were fantastic and deserve to be recognized. Not only were they both incredibly polite, and very helpful to me and everyone else shopping but they were constantly working (reorganizing shelves, assisting customers with self check out, helping with pick up orders) and going out of their way to offer extra assistance to everyone in the store! Its incredibly rare to see this level of customer service these days and these two were absolute stars!! I really hope five below management reads these reviews and acknowledges them both.”

  2. 550 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove NY 11755

    3.8 Good 115 reviews

    “This store fye has been around since I been in high school. As the years go on things change but this store always has been one of go tos. Yesterday I went in to the store, I was greeted, I know its a bit slow side in retail. I actually received help yesterday by tom who was very nice young man. He found what I needed rang me up, he very sweet. With those memberships- if you actually take the time to listen or even look at the card, paper they ask you want it tells you. I had it for years. On and off.. Fye is a great store for years and hopefully will be around for years to come.”

  3. 1851 Sunrise Highway Suite 7, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.3 Superb 133 reviews

    “My question is why are half the registers closed? It's a great store tho my local five below! I always love finding Lisa Frank stickers crochet etc not such a big place but have good Candy's and snacks along with finding such great board games and slime and plushies.”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 5507 Nesconset Hwy # 12A, Mt Sinai NY 11766

    4.5 Superb 46 reviews

    “This place was my 1st experience with buying wacky tabaki LEGALLY (?). The gentleman who helped me was pretty awesome. Super kind and knowledgeable. DIDN'T try to get me to buy more expensive items. Was so genuine. Loved it.”

  6. 787 Middle Country Rd #17C, Selden NY 11784

    4.6 Superb 14 reviews

    “THE BEST FIVE BELOW AROUND!!!! STAFF IS THE BEST NEVER EVER NASTY ! I CAN CALL ALL DAY EVERYDAY AND THEY ALWAYS ANSWER THE PHONE ALWAYS HONEST HELPFUL NEVER MEAN ! SHOUTOUT TO MIKE AND I FORGOT HER NAME BUT SHE ANSWERS ALMOST EVERY MORNING SHES SO SWEET !”

  7. 371 Smithtown Bypass, Hauppauge NY 11788

    4.5 Superb 15 reviews

  8. 1735 Union Blvd, Bay Shore NY 11706

    4.1 Good 32 reviews

    “This is a great store with excellent staff. Always friendly and helpful. Go often, since stock can change and there are great values to be found in every isle. Save yourself money and time and support a local business.”

  9. 499-15 Sunrise Highway, Patchogue NY 11772

    4 Good 54 reviews

    “We come in here all the time squishy hunting, the management here has come up with a fair way of distribution and are always super helpful/sweet to my kids. We've been to other 5 bellows and they're always very chaotic.”

  10. 2280 North Ocean Avenue Suite C, Farmingville NY 11738

    3.8 Good 47 reviews

    “Amazing staff, they are so nice and sweet the managers Nick and Spencer try to accommodate as much as possible and really make the store a welcome place for kids and adults. Even when some of the customers are rude and nasty the staff stay calm and don't engage. I watched a customer scream at the employees for no reason at all and the staff literally said im sorry youre having a hard day. When the person walked out I said how did you stay so calm and the employee said I think its just the heat or she must be having a bad day. You can't make somone fake being that compassionate they just are really good people dealing with a lot of difficult situations with poise and character.”

  11. 4054 Nesconset Highway Ste 2A, Setauket- East Setauket NY 11733

    3.8 Good 42 reviews

    “Five below East setuaket I’m pasting this comment from my Girlfriend to you guys as she can’t login using her credentials. To Five Below I went shopping at five below in East Setuaket. Around 6pm on October 3, 2024, the was a man Asssociate and a Manager who both were very professional and friendly.The Manager helped me scan my items and so so caring and had great communication skills.Both Associates are a true asset to your company.I was telling her about my gift card I got today during my Chemotherapy treatment at the cancer center. The manager is a real caring compassion person.I Love Five Below store especially this store. Danielle”

  12. 1825 Brentwood Rd, Brentwood NY 11717

    3.4 Good 5 reviews

    • Today 9AM – 7PM
  13. 1701 Sunrise Hwy Space D12, Bay Shore NY 11706

    3.2 Average 9 reviews

Advertisement

Variety Stores in nearby cities

Related topics

  • 20,000th Dollar General Store Now Open

    Dollar General opened its 20,000th U.S. store on February 24th in Alice, Texas. It’s a major milestone for the discount chain that started as one small general store back in 1955. Starting with a ribbon cutting ceremony, the grand opening celebration began at 9am. First customers received some freebies - tote bags filled with free product samples and snacks from DG's Clover Valley brand.

    Read the post