Thrift Stores near Lancaster, NY

16 locations found near Lancaster
View Map

“This was an unexpected pleasant stop! The outside is very deceiving -hiding the gems inside. Tons of stuff inside! The proprietor was very nice to chat with and welcoming. The store was well organized and clean!!”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“Second Chic is an absolute gem of a thrift store. The moment you step in, you're greeted with a unique shopping experience that is both exciting and satisfying. The store is filled with a wide array of designer clothes that are in excellent condition and sold at a range of pricesThe unique vintage clothes tell a story, and the quality is simply outstanding. The selection is diverse, catering to a variety of styles and tastes. Whether you're looking for a classic Chanel piece or a quirky 70s dress, you're likely to find it here.The store layout is well-organized, making it easy to browse through the clothes. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, always ready to help you find the perfect piece.”

4.7 Superb51 Reviews

“I love the atmosphere of this store the owner is always singing and always has gospel music on which is pleasant and nice to listen to while shopping i have found some great deals there on some days and not on others that is what thrifting is all about keep up the good work all the coworkers are very friendly and outgoing”

4 Good56 Reviews

“This store has the best prices of all the Goodwill's in WNY! Some of the other locations have priced their items so high that I don't bother going to them any longer. The staff and manager at this location are terrific! The store is very neat and organized. It would be nice to see the restrooms at all Goodwill locations reopen.”

4.1 Good44 Reviews

“Great place to stop by and find some interesting items. Place was pretty clean and organized. Tijuana was a fantastic help and super nice to everyone she interacted with. I’d go back just to tell her how great she was.”

3.9 Good54 Reviews

“It was my first time in this store. The person with whom I was traveling and I expressed an interest in this store. The vast majority of the merchandise is of children's clothes, and more like a thrifts store, although I sid make a quick browse. I happily found a book with a felt black cat on the cover, and I was very happy to buy it. I believe there are a few Finders Keepers stores.”

3.7 Good44 Reviews

“The best Goodwill I’ve been to! Great finds for decent prices, all very clean and organized, and friendly staff. Will definitely include this location in my sustainable fashion repertoire.”

3.5 Good73 Reviews

“The best thrifting experience in WNY. There are so many cute toddlers’ clothes and tons of name brand womens’ clothing that are in great shape. The staff were so friendly and even gave my daughter a sticker and a cute play necklace Will definitely be back!”

3.5 Good34 Reviews

“Great selection and pricing! I appreciate how they lay out their home goods and tchotchki's. Huge selection of men's, women's, and childrens clothing at this location. The staff is super friendly here and goes out of their way to help load items in, when needed.”

3.4 Good32 Reviews