Creepy Creatures is a highly recommended animal store specializing in reptiles and exotic pets. Customers praise the staff for their extensive knowledge and friendly, helpful attitude. They are known for providing excellent care advice and helping with sick or new pets, ensuring animals like leopard geckos and white tree frogs receive proper treatment and supplies. The store offers a wide variety of creatures, including snakes, spiders, frogs, geckos, isopods, springtails, and crickets, making it a favorite for families and pet enthusiasts alike. Visitors enjoy meeting and interacting with the animals, such as vinageroons, and appreciate the staff’s willingness to answer questions and provide complete care kits. Many customers feel their pets' health and happiness improved after visiting Creepy Creatures, with some expressing gratitude for rescuing their pets from poor conditions. The store is praised for its cleanliness, knowledgeable staff, and great selection of food and supplies. Overall, Creepy Creatures is viewed as a caring, reliable, and top-quality place for exotic pets and reptile care, with customers eager to return.
Store associate was very friendly and the store has lots of variety of cool reptiles/inverts
April 2026
Great place. High level of knowledge an customer. Service.
February 2026
For those who like 'exotic' pets , this is one of my favorite places to get them . Tanks , heater stones , bedding , if the don't have it , odds are they can get it for you . Entrance is in back of the store . On Main Street south of the Babylon branch of the LIRR .
