Liberty Pet & Supply is a well-regarded pet store known for its knowledgeable and friendly staff. Customers appreciate the clean and well-organized environment, offering a wide variety of animals including puppies, lizards, tarantulas, fish, and birds. The store also stocks an extensive range of pet supplies such as food, leashes, and beds. While some items may be priced higher than competitors, many shoppers prefer to support this local business over larger retailers like Walmart or Amazon. Overall, Liberty Pet & Supply is praised for its superior service and well-cared-for animals, making it a favorite destination for pet owners.
Prices are a bit high but worth it if you can't get to the chain stores in Middletown and beyond. They have a large selection.
August 2025
Nice pet store, friendly staff. You can buy bulk feed by the pound there.
March 2025
Great pet store, I go here often. Definitely a little more pricey than other places you can get the stuff, but I’d rather give them my money than Walmart or Amazon. I also get live rats here for my snake. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly, the place is clean and well organized. It’s a great spot!
