-
February 2026 by Jaqueline
Everything was good in general, they were very on time for a times square Restaurant. Make a reservation or you Will not be seated.
-
February 2026 by Sue
Always a great choice meeting up wth friends in NYC. Great value, great food and great service. Large portions. Never disappointed in Carmines!
-
February 2026 by Sam
Made an 8:30PM reservation for 2 on Sunday night. Even with the reservation we were seated about 15 minutes after arrival. The service was excellent, the waiter was friendly and very attentive. Unfortunately the place is very LOUD (as it is popular), we were also informed that the kitchen was having issue and were restricted on what we could order. To make up for the difference management offered free dessert. The food (although not hot) tasted absolutely amazing and the portion was perfect for 2 people. Overall not the best experience but I will return once the kitchen issue is resolved.
-
February 2026 by Doug
This was our third time at Carmine‘s in New York City, and we were very disappointed. The atmosphere was loud, our server was not attentive at all. We felt rushed to order and were not offered refills on drinks or dessert. We ordered the mixed seafood, pasta was extremely starchy and the seafood was sparse. Would not recommend. The highlight of the meal was the Caesar salad.
-
February 2026 by Alexandre
Everything was marvelous and my suggestion is the waiting list be present at the TV instead of hearing the hosts calling the names
-
February 2026 by Candace
The food, the staff, the energy when it comes to singing and celebrating birthdays are 10/10
-
February 2026 by Tara
My family's experience was mediocre at best this time. Carmine's ran out of pasta which significantly limited the available menu options. Also, one bathroom was out of service leading to long lines to use the women's room. Prior experiences at this restaurant were better.
-
February 2026 by Krista
If I could give a rating higher than 5 stars, I would. Thank you to Esaie and his incredible staff. Everyone was communicative, friendly, personable, helpful and SMILING. They created a warm and inviting experience from start to finish. The food was delicious as always, the service was spectacular and despite how busy it always is, the servers are so very attentive. There's a reason that Carmine's is always packed no matter what day or time it is - the food, the service and the experience are TOP NOTCH. you feel good walking in and even better walking out. Thank you Esaie and Carmine's!
-
January 2026 by Elise
The food and the service were impeccable. Make sure you have a large party or are very hungry! The portions are family style and HUGE!
-
January 2026 by Silvia
The food was cold and it was not good (lasagna, and chicken). We saw other people's food really hot (spaghetti ) and ours was not. It was like if our food was already done because it didn't even take 10 minutes from the time we ordered it for it to be served to us.
-
January 2026 by Alice
We had a great dinner after seeing a Broadway show on Sunday. I have a gluten allergy and the server was knowledgeable and I got safe with the food we had. All of the dishes were delicious. We had the Titanic for dessert which was so good. Our waiter was friendly and attentive. The restaurant was very busy but the food came out quickly. Overall, a fun place with really good food.
-
January 2026 by Helena
Our experience last night at Carmine's was awesome! Our waiter Adrian was awesome and beyond accommodating for our party. Can't wait to go back! Thank you, Adrian!
-
January 2026 by Mariano
Muy buena y abundante comida, la atención es destacable y la orientación de los mozos y mozas fundamental para pedir correctamente.
-
January 2026 by Crystal
It was appearing that our 7 pm was just a suggestion but the bartender was fun to watch and it wasn't too long after that we got a table. Our waiter was so helpful as I didn't realize that everything is served family style. And a party of two could have had a lot of food left over. Even sharing a salad and an entree we had food left over. We met fellow diners next to us and had a great conversation. Fun night!
-
January 2026 by Jacob
Adrian was honestly the most amazing service i have ever had! He was friendly and honestly made the experience everything! Would go back again especially if i got to sit as his table again!!!
