Thrift Stores near Mamaroneck, NY

14 locations found near Mamaroneck

“I would highly recommend!! They always have something, I went there today for the first time! I ended up spending $40. I got a leather bag for $10, a new with tags dress from Nordstrom’s (Nordstrom rack actually) for $9, another dress for $6, a pair of Birkenstocks used for $5, a pair of leather suede riding boots for $12, a necklace for $5 (she knocked a few bucks off, so I think it ended up being $3, and an old vintage leather wrap? Belt? That was leather and suede from Bloomingdale’s made in France for Bloomie’s. And that’s my haul.
Some items are not priced so they’ll price it in front of you and they’ll give you a good price too.’the women running it are nice”

3.9 Good10 Reviews

“It’s a small neighborhood thrift store, but honestly, it’s better than expected. While it doesn’t have the huge selection you’d find in larger thrift stores, the items are nicely curated with a lot of vintage charm, making it fun to browse.

Prices are very affordable, so it’s a great spot if you’re looking for good deals. If you’re lucky, you can definitely find some hidden gems—it’s very much a “treasure hunt” kind of place.

The staff are friendly, and the overall vibe is warm and welcoming. That said, the store is on the smaller side and not perfectly organized, so it’s best to take your time and look around carefully.

A small but charming thrift shop where you can score great finds if luck is on your side”

4.7 Superb43 Reviews

“Probably my favorite thrift at the moment. Not only do they have a wide selection of merchandise at amazing prices, but the church it supports is an open, welcoming and inclusive church! The volunteers/staff are always friendly and helpful. There is always great turn around of merchandise, I always find something new when I go, which is quite often. They’ve done an overhaul of the layout and it’s been a great change. Everything is always neatly organized and displayed in well-curated manners.”

4.8 Superb22 Reviews

“Wonderful shop with such a lovely owner, along with her cute pup Dean, who greeted us amiably at the door. Lots to peruse here, from cool vintage clothing to fun household items. My sisters and I will definitely be returning to shop at this cool place, easily accessible from the tristate area. Come visit, you won’t be disappointed!”

4.5 Superb32 Reviews

“A very cute place that has super affordable inventory! Definitely cheaper than other places. I got two nice tops for $3. Super sweet staff too. I'll be back soon! :)”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“(Translated by Google) A great blessing that there is always help for all families very good people(Original)Una gran bendición q siempre ay ayuda para todas las familias muy buenas personas”

4.6 Superb32 Reviews

“Nice, friendly, clean and reasonable prices on all there items. No junk. Will always visit when I get a chance. Thank you for making what thrift store should be.”

4.3 Superb38 Reviews

“Staff is very nice and willing to help you with pricing questions. Thrift store is on the smaller side with the majority of the space being used for women's clothing/shoes. There is a smaller room for men's clothing/shoes and another room for houseware and small furniture pieces. Treasures can definitely be found at a great price. Store had dozens of nice coats and leather jackets.”

4.5 Superb6 Reviews

“Great quality items at reasonable prices. I picked up a few gorgeous home pieces, and there was an excellent selection to choose from. They were even running a promotion that added an extra 50% off the plates and 75% off the quilt.”

4.2 Good54 Reviews

“Golden Shoestring is such a gem! This nonprofit organization is always busy, and it’s no surprise why—there are incredible deals on clothing and jewelry donations. You can find high-quality items at amazing prices, and it feels great knowing that shopping here supports a good cause. Highly recommend stopping by to score some unique finds and support the community! PS ask for Jodi - she’s amazing!!!”

4.1 Good23 Reviews

“Entering this historic home containing 3 amazing rooms is like entering a museum with its finely curated assortment of china, glassware, crystal, accessories, lamps, artwork, jewelry, furniture, tools, handmade artistry, and so much more too numerous to mention. One will walk out with an armful as the prices are unspeakably modest for the superb quality offered. This shop is a treasure trove of goods which run the gamut from historic, vintage, one of a kind, rare finds to contemporary. Plan to spend time just looking and recalling nostalgia. The shop offers a special sale each month highlighting an inventory of items brought in each week by generous donors and liquidated estates. There is something for everyone, but definitely a must see. The shop, now under new management, has a unified group of dedicated volunteers with a keen eye for interior design. Each room is staged with a theme of items organized and categorized neatly making it buyer friendly. Please visit a most welcoming venue for old and new and everything in between. Knowing that all proceeds from sales go to St. Gregory the Enlightener Armenian Church is satisfying. This shop has it all but mostly, you will love what you see every Thursday afternoon from 12-4pm and announced monthly Saturdays. It's such a treat!”

3.2 Average9 Reviews

“This was an easy and straight forward experience. I came in, deposited my donation, a receipt was provided and I left. It was an easy process, I recommend this location to anyone looking to donate.”

3.7 Good80 Reviews

“I’ve just recently started shopping at this location, and I have been so impressed with the staff - in particular Carlton and Peter. If I had the names of the ladies that worked here I’d add them as well! Everyone is lovely. I’ve thrifted long before it was viral and trendy, and in my opinion all thrift / second hand stores have raised prices- i still find this particular store reasonable. The selection is great and i always find treasures. This has been wonderful for me as in on a weight loss journey - so buying retail st this point doesn’t make sense. I’ve also donated, and found that process incredibly easy. Happy customer here !!!!”

3.6 Good101 Reviews

“Very confused reading the other reviews because I love this store. Store hours are clearly posted and great finds in clothing and housewares along with jewelry, handbags and shoes. Staff especially the manager are very nice.”

3.1 Average70 Reviews