-
April 2024 by Kylee M.
Brilliant! Door dashed to our hotel that was 10 minutes away and got it delivered in 15! However, sizes were very small for the price we payed. Chocolate overload was my favorite flavor. It was delicious with chocolate chips, hunks of brownies, and chocolate swirl all in chocolate ice cream! However, I do not recommend the cherry Italian ice. Unless you like the taste of air fresheners. over all I would recommend this to anyone.
-
March 2024 by Nysports Mcp
Good ice cream, but Snowflake in Riverhead is better.
-
March 2024 by Christian Trujillo
Great service! Was surprised how easy it was to order a custom cake online. And it came out great. They placed the image I requested, and the letters used for the inscription looked perfect. Just had to get the decorations from Amazon. Will definitely come back in the summer. Thanks!
-
January 2024 by Theo
OVERRATED...AGAIN OVERRATED
-
January 2024 by Dan 03
Nostalgic and delicious. The only downside is it's small and you feel crowded with just 6 people inside.Parking: Not much parking, we parked in what looks like a second lot. You are better off biking to the place.
-
January 2024 by Tanya Barrett
For an ice cream shop it rocks.
-
October 2023 by Serena Woods
I love the variety. This place is the best!!!
-
October 2023 by Christina H
Moved away a couple years back and I still drive back here to get a box of Toni’s!! The best!!
-
October 2023 by ramonescommando
Yes, the ice cream is top notch. But it's really expensive. The staff enjoy talking to each other socially as you stand and wait. ALSO, while paying by card the option of giving a 10%, 20% tip was offered. Serving ice cream may pay poorly, but it felt uncomfortable to see. I'm not cheap, I do tip (when appropriate), this seems invasive. How do I know the servers get the tips?
-
October 2023 by Sophia P.
Ice Cream Cottage had not only some of the best flavors but uniqueness to each of them. I had a great experience here, enjoyed the ice cream and would recommend this place for some of the best ice cream Long Island has to offer!
-
September 2023 by Kara Galante
Excellent local Ice-cream establishment, the consistency is amazing and the variety is excellent, they are affordable and have a variety of candy available for purchase.
-
August 2023 by Bartenders2go LLC
Best homemade ice cream and flavor selections!
-
August 2023 by Vanessa Wirth
Love it here! The strawberry cheesecake ice cream is my absolute fav!
-
August 2023 by Khemran Ramesar
Best ice-cream you can get!!Service is remarkable
-
August 2023 by Sal Verdi
Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had.. the staff is very helpful and oo did i mention some if the best ice crèam on long island?
