Montauk Native Gasoline is a well-loved gas station known for its friendly staff and great prices. Customers appreciate the full-service experience, where employees go the extra mile by pumping gas and delivering cigarettes, especially for those with mobility challenges. Many note that the gas prices, especially for diesel, are the best on Long Island, often cheaper than larger chains like Costco and BJs. The store also offers a large selection of goods, making it a convenient stop. While some mention the location can be tricky to find and the cleanliness could improve, the overall value and welcoming atmosphere keep customers returning, often praising the staff for their humor and kindness.
the store's employees are always courteous and helpful And I love that their stores always clean and always have been since I started coming here which has been since 2014
May 2026
Very good prices very good service and the manager is very cute
February 2025
I didn't know a place like this actually existed. Really cool place
