Paint Stores near Mastic, NY

1495 Montauk Hwy #6, Mastic NY 11950

4.3 Superb 29 reviews

• Closed today
• (631) 775-8135

“True old school paint store. No gimmicks or BS. The experienced staff are old school too. If you need experience to get your project done, this is your place. Benjamin Moore products are #1.”

469 Montauk Hwy, East Moriches NY 11940

5 Superb 55 reviews

• Today 9AM – 2PM
• (631) 878-0200

“I was shopping with my daughter & grandson at the East Moriches Hardware Store …they were picking up some paint for their new home, I was trying to keep my grandson busy, while my daughter was shopping …the gentlemen running this business couldn’t be any nicer …I think it’s the owner but I’m not100% sure ..but he was so sweet to us while my grandson was getting a little mischievous😂 so just a little shout out to say thank you for being so patient and kind …My pictures will explain what happened …. Merry Christmas!”

800 Montauk Hwy, Shirley NY 11967

5 Superb 32 reviews

• Today 10AM – 4PM
• (631) 281-9641

“Shopping at the Sherwin Williams in Shirley is always a 5 star experience..there knowledgeable and if they don't have an answer immediately they will research products and call us back to make sure we have the right product for the situation”

900 NY-25A, Miller Place NY 11764

4.6 Superb 107 reviews

• Today 8AM – 6PM
• (631) 209-1462

“Very well stocked hardware store (about to become larger with a move down the road, construction in progress). Expert paint color matching to a sample from your wall, worked perfectly both times I used this service.”

1704 Old Country Rd, Riverhead NY 11901

4.2 Good 18 reviews

• Today 10AM – 4PM
• (631) 727-1616

“Nice helpful staff at Riverhead. Once you realize the ease and quality of a paint job is using great quality paint and brush/rollers...you will never use cheap stuff again. S-W is the best!!”

360 NY-25A, Rocky Point NY 11778

4.5 Superb 42 reviews

• Today 8AM – 6PM
• (631) 392-1206

“I had to return an opened box item without the box, but with the receipt and the defective product. I was concerned because I had tossed the box and put it out in the recycling. The young manager was kind and professional. He helped me pick out the replacement item and quickly had me on my way. Very impressive. Thank you. journal# C43880 I forgot his name..”