Butchers near Mattituck, NY

4 locations found near Mattituck

Filters
Rating
Distance
  1. 11155 NY-25, Mattituck NY 11952

    4.4 Superb 73 reviews

    “100% of the time we shop in this butcher shop, we leave satisfied. Yes, their meats and sides are all premium but it’s more about the amazing customer service. Today, we went in to buy baby back ribs, and got way more than we asked! An offer to spice them up, wrap them up in an oven pan and directions on exactly how to cook them. All with a smile and lots of grace. Highly recommend!!”

  2. 143 Main St, Southampton NY 11968

    5 Superb 24 reviews

    “Catena’s is the best of its breed — and what a rare breed it is: a blend of third-generation molto-friendly service with seafood, meats, and prepared foods of the highest quality. A list of my extraordinarily delicious takeouts would overrun the limits of this space. Suffice it to say that the storefront behind the Catena’s Market awning is a gem of the Hamptons. Don F.”

  3. 235 N Sea Rd, Southampton NY 11968

    4.4 Superb 70 reviews

    “Best butcher shop in area. There house made sausage are terrific , don’t shrink when bbqd. D’Artanion chicken & lamb chops are the best anywhere. Steve is a very knowledgeable butcher.”

  4. Advertisement

  5. 55575 NY-25, Southold NY 11971

    3.3 Good 174 reviews

    “Wayside has all the best attributes of an old-school butcher - great cuts of meat, encyclopedic knowledge of how to cook them and impeccable service - plus the local farm connections and amazing prepared foods you would find in a high-end market. The deli is a great stop for delicious sandwiches at reasonable prices; the butcher is a place to find extraordinary locally sourced meat or - more economically - a unique burger blend. Must-stop for grilling on the north fork.”

Advertisement

Butchers in nearby cities