Handy Pantry in Mattituck is special. Been going there for a sandwich for lunch since high school. They make great sandwiches and is a great stop for grabbing cold cuts and basic groceries. Some items are priced higher than a grocery store, but others are cheaper and everything is great quality. Plenty of beer too.
March 2024
Quite clean environment!!!!Customer service =E X C E L L E N T!!
March 2023
Everything I get here is usually good and open all day but staff is generally rude and not a big fan of their sanitation practices.
Handy Pantry is more than just a convenience store—it’s your neighborhood market and deli, offering fresh, made-to-order sandwiches, high-quality deli meats, and essential groceries, all in one place. Unlike typical chain convenience stores, we focus on freshness, quality, and a personal touch. Whether you're grabbing a quick coffee, stocking up on essentials, or ordering a delicious sub, Handy Pantry delivers a local, community-driven shopping experience with a wide selection of fresh food, snacks, and everyday necessities. Stop by and see why we’re a cut above the rest!
