Mattituck Marketplace is a local market that offers an impressive selection of fresh produce at competitive prices, according to reviews. The market is known for its excellent sandwiches, but some customers have found the overall prices to be high. While the market is well-stocked, customers have reported issues with expired dairy products and rotten produce, so it's important to check expiration dates. The market also features a fantastic wine shop with a variety of local wines, though the Starbucks location has since closed.
I went there last Easter Week Everything in the supermarket was very clean and organized. and everything in the Meat Department was really fresh, I got a piece of lamb and it was delicious highly recommend to do grocery’s there!
March 2026
Everything is organized and clean. Highly recommend
September 2025
I got what I was looking for and it's a great convenience to have that store on the East end.
