-
March 2024 by Sarah S
Do not place an online order with them. They charge you even if they are not open and never receive your ice cream. When my mother called to dispute the charge (because we never received the ice cream) they treated her with incredible disrespect and told her that she would be subject to a 10% service charge for cancelling.
-
March 2024 by Jessica L.
Not a lot of room inside but there are some benches outside. They have great flavor options.
-
March 2024 by Connor
Ice cream was good but not worth $8 for basically 1 scoop! Felt like I was getting pressured just trying to buy ice cream.
-
February 2024 by Samuel Mack
Some awsome coffee ice
-
February 2024 by Paul DiGaudio
Great ?
-
January 2024 by Audrey
The BEST ice cream on Long Island! We have been stopping here for years. A must stop on your way to the East End. You will not be disappointed. So many ice cream flavors. Everyone loves the Magic Fountain including our dogs ??
-
January 2024 by Vanilla Bean
No because why was the server such a passive aggressive. Whoever was working today afternoon was absolutely ridiculous. My experience was disgusting. There was a group and they haven’t decided what they wanted so I grabbed a raspberry parfait and was ready to be rung up and she waited for this group of people to decide what they wanted like 5mins later. And then once they finally decide they pay and leave and then has the audacity to say “I think this group was next” to a group who hasn’t even decided what they wanted either. What kind of person just waits for people to make up their mind while others are waiting to be rung up? This server should definitely learn how to multi task and learn how to work more efficiently because come on girl. Idk her name she had glasses.Ice cream was good tho.
-
January 2024 by Jennifer R.
I've been to Magic Fountain a few times and enjoyed it each time. You place your order inside with friendly staff (you can try a flavor or two to be sure you like what you're ordering) and there's an extensive menu of flavors. The outside has a few benches and a cute mural and some vintage inspired signage in front. I can't wait to return this summer!
-
November 2023 by KK Rearview
This ice cream is always worth the wait.
-
October 2023 by Tommy D
The icecream selection was awesome - server was very nice - it was packed at the end of October a sign it's a good
-
October 2023 by barry rokash
pints to go? order ahead, delicious and an amazing staff here. thank you
-
October 2023 by Ken L.
Excellent product. Many flavors, friendly efficient staff. Order in advance for pickup or you may be waiting a while outside on li e.
-
October 2023 by Pennington Knickernacker
Doesn't matter if it's middle of the night, 20 below zero, they've got a line out the door. Almond Joy ice cream, you know you want it!
-
October 2023 by amanda eagleston
Best Homemade Ice Cream on Long Island! So many flavors to choose from.
-
October 2023 by Mantas
This is the best ice cream in Suffolk County! The staff is super knowledgeable and friendly, and can whip up any flavor you want if it’s not on the menu. They do birthday cakes as well! Doggy treats? They got them! If you’re in the mood for ice cream. This is the only place to visit.
