Crosby's - Mayville
Convenience StoresHours:
14 N Erie St, Mayville NY 14757 Hours
About Crosby's - Mayville
Crosby's is appreciated for its friendly and helpful staff, especially during shifts with Tammy Nuse. Customers praise her for making accurate, quick orders and going above and beyond to ensure satisfaction. The store is kept in great condition, reflecting strong customer service. Food like subs and pizzas is consistently fresh and made to order. Staff members, including Amanda, Robert, and Angelica, are recognized for their excellent service, making visits enjoyable and memorable. Overall, Crosby's is known for good food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere, especially when staff like Tammy are working.
Most Recent Reviews
April 2026
The 2 ladies that worked closing shift on 4/22/26 were absolutely AMAZING!!! Our chicken wing pizza was cooked to perfection, the customer service was top of the line , definitely 5 star service!
July 2025
Fantastic fresh homemade pizza-by-the-slice! And even has more unusual toppings available too.
January 2025
We love going their when Tammy nuse is working. She make our orders correct and super fast and she goes above and beyond to make sure your order is correct and she's very friendly.
More Comments(25)
You May Also Like
0.95 miles
Kwik Fill Gas Station, Convenience Store6.06 miles
7-Eleven Electronics Store, Convenience Store
- Mayville, New York
