Island Thrift offers a variety of items, including clothes, dishes, glasses, toys, and vintage pieces. Customers often find unique treasures and appreciate the spacious and organized layout of the store. Many shoppers enjoy the thrill of hunting for deals, especially on weekends when certain color tags are half off. However, there is a recurring theme in the reviews regarding the pricing of items. While some customers find reasonable deals, others feel that many household items are priced higher than what they would pay in regular stores, with some items being close to retail prices.
Though the store is noted for its cleanliness and selection, shoppers have expressed disappointment over the pricing strategy and the inconsistency of sales. Additionally, some customers have experienced issues with store policies, particularly regarding locked items. Overall, Island Thrift is seen as a mixed bag, where browsing can be enjoyable, but shoppers should be prepared for variable prices that may not always reflect thrift store expectations.
There are a few Island Thrifts around...and like any thrift experience, it all depends on what is there to say it was a good experience or not. There are so many options at all of them! It takes time to look through the racks and shelves so if you have the time, enjoy. You can come away with a great find or empty-handed.... read full comment
August 2026
Store is clean, well-lit, and easy to navigate, however, the prices are unreal. Many of the items you could find brand-new for less than they are charging here. Parking is also a bit of a nightmare.
April 2026
Increasing prices, I get it. Barely cleaning, I get it. Splitting sets, writing their stupid prices in marker that doesn't come off, rude staff, posting sale colors that are not actually on sale, I don't get it.
