Jewelry Stores in Middletown, NY

10 locations found near Middletown

“Jessica was an amazing help! She remembered me from the week prior and helped me pick a beautiful engagement ring. She even modeled it on hand for me and worked a great deal. Amazing personality and energy if you’re checking out zales in Middletown galleria ask for Jessica.”

4.8 Superb203 Reviews

“Kris and Lissett is family now! I have been coming here for years and years.. If I could give this place 100 stars, I would. These ladies are amazing! They have seen all stages of our family from being pregnant, bringing my son at 2 months to visit and now hes 4 and goes in to chit chat about animals with the girls. They watched my daughter go from being pregnant to a grieving mom who lost her son, my grandson. They offered so much support during our extremely difficult time. We love these ladies so much.. not only are they personally invested in having quality relationships with their customers but their knowledge on their products is top tier and they have such a large variety of products. They've helped me become a more non toxic household as well. Thank you ladies so much ! See you guys soon.”

4.9 Superb66 Reviews

“My daughter wanted her ears pierced for her birthday. She was nervous, but Emily and Deb were amazing!! They reassured her and pierced both sides at the same time. Definitely will be back to visit them in the future. What a quick and great experience!! ❤❤”

4.8 Superb138 Reviews

“I had a fantastic experience at Kay Jewelers thanks to Kaylah! She took the time to answer all my questions and helped me out with so much patience, warmth, and professionalism. It’s refreshing to get such attentive and genuinely helpful service. Highly recommend asking for her if you stop by!”

4.7 Superb146 Reviews

“I took two Seiko watches for repair and they were done in two days. Serpentini Jewelry & Watch Services is an excellent. Rich is very friendly and knowledgeable and professional. Repair prices are very reasonable, I was very happy with my watches and to see them both working as they should.”

4.8 Superb42 Reviews

“Great customer service. I brung my watch here to fix and I received a excellent customer service and the work that was done on my watch epic. Ty Butter cup Jewelry.”

4.8 Superb33 Reviews

“Tom runs a wonderful local coin shop in Middletown NY… I have purchased several constitutional silver pieces over the past few weeks. Not only did I get great prices, Tom provided me the complete historic background of each coin!

Tom/Dart stamp is now my “go to” resource as I learn and develop my new hobby and grow my stack!”

4.7 Superb63 Reviews

“I came in based on good reviews to have a ring resized. There was only a day or two before I needed it, this had to be a fast job so I was worried. Also the ring was sentimental and the people I worked with needed to be trustworthy.

When I dropped the ring off I had a very friendly interaction with the staff there. They must be family because that's the type of love they display for their business and their customers. I dropped the ring off with them hoping I would be able to get it in time for when I needed it.

The next day, I got a call while I was working and the woman I left the ring with explained it was done and ready for pickup. That was very fast I was expecting at least a few days!

I was unable to make it out to the shop until another day went by and they held my ring for me. When I got there and picked it up it was more beautiful than I've ever seen it. They cleaned it up and I'm really impressed with the craftsmanship and result. The prices are reasonable, the staff is kind, this is the place to go in the area for your jewelry needs. Avoid big names, support small business, meet people like these and get good work done. Thank you and God bless!”

4.6 Superb50 Reviews

“I love this shop. It’s got some metaphysical items, Asian culture items, and even native stuff! It is a little bit pricey. The employees are insanely nice! They usually have a good selection of on sale items, and they have a lot of gemstones and Crystals, which Are somewhat expensive. They have different brands of packaged stones and gems, not sure which are real and which aren’t.”

4.2 Good10 Reviews

“I had an outstanding experience thanks to Yohanna! From the moment I walked in, she was warm, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable about the products. She took her time helping me find exactly what I was looking for, offering thoughtful suggestions without ever being pushy. Her professionalism and friendly attitude made the entire shopping experience enjoyable and stress free.

Yohanna’s attention to detail and genuine care for her customers truly set her apart. She made sure I left confident and happy with my purchase. Pandora is lucky to have such a dedicated and personable associate on their team.”

4 Good79 Reviews