-
January 2024 by Kaitlin C
Incredible pasta! Can't wait to come back and try more dishes. Great spot with a cozy atmosphere - highly
-
January 2024 by Sandra Funk
Went with a couple friends and the food was delicious. I had the shrimp with pink sauce it was so good! A must in MontaukParking: Limited parking up top but a huge parking area on the side of the manor building. Unfortunately the elevator is not working.
-
January 2024 by Alayna Effron
If I could give more stars, I would! Cozy up in this incredibly warm, beautiful and inviting environment. The menu is impeccable - and the food is so good, you can smell it down the block. Our entire experience was completely elevated by the unparalleled service and hospitality....LISA! Lisa was a total gem!! She was attentive, thoughtful, knowledgeable and cheerful - we never needed for anything! If I could give HER gold stars, I would!
-
January 2024 by Niko Hat
A hip joint for locals and tourists alike. Classy service and cool ambience. The menu showcases local seafoods and the classic Italian American fare that the Monte’s are known for. The sauce boss PJ might be at the host podium to greet you before you order an expertly crafted martini. Indulge on awesome appetizers like the classic “shrimp Monte” the fun “stretch” and the elegant swordfish meatballs. Have a glass of Chianti and don’t miss the chicken parm, fluke picatta or one of the awesome pastas for the main course! Finish the night right with a decadent tiramisu. Will definitely return every time I’m back in montauk!
-
January 2024 by Sam Pezz.
A fantastic and unique addition to the Montauk/Hamptons restaurant scene. The food is delicious and the atmosphere is a throwback! Will definitely be back thanks to the exceptional service we received from our friendly server Lisa!!
-
January 2024 by Leah Vallario
Montes brings such a modern vibe to the manor. The food is so good and our server Daniel was great
-
December 2023 by Russ M.
Spent a night over New Years weekend and had a great time. Staff was totally on point. This was our second time there this year and will definetly doing more frequent trips to the Manor. Room was awesome. Super clean and set up perfectly.
-
December 2023 by David Yontef
Excellent experience!!! This was my second time back in a month and went with friends to celebrate holiday time. The place has a real magical with an old school vibe. It’s like time stops in there and the good vibes flow!!! Lisa helped us with a warm energy and set the tone for our evening, making excellent menu recommendations. The owners were beyond welcoming and vibrant. There was a special feeling in there and the food was delicious. Every bite. Group favorites were definitely the stretch, fluke, chicken parm (x3) , chicken Milanese and grandmas meatballs!!! Of course the rainbow cake is a must. Thank you Monte’s for an amazing time and memories. We’ll all be back!
-
December 2023 by Eileen G.
Great stay! The staff was so friendly and very happy to welcome you. Great views of the bay from our patio!
-
December 2023 by Robert Vanderhoof
I have been an owner at the Montauk Manor for over 20 years and I have to say that tonight was by far the best dinner I have ever experienced!The staff was amazing, the atmosphere was that of a time long ago when you were treated with respect and kindness...and the food...well let me just say, it was absolutely beyond anything I could have ever imagined!Bravo to the Monte family for creating a place where we can all feel like part of their family!
-
December 2023 by Jenny Vatore
Good food with reasonable price ?
-
December 2023 by JoJo A.
The Montauk Manor is iconic. The history of the building combined with the beauty of it makes for a unique experience. I always feel any experience is better when the staff is good. At the Montauk Manor all of the staff members are amazing, dedicated and overall wonderful. If you have the opportunity to stay there you should jump on it. The rooms are clean and well maintained, the grounds are beautiful, the lobby is spectacular. The lobby makes you feel like you took a ride back to the roaring 20's and all it's glamour and splendor! Over the past few months they have opened the restaurant, Monte's, which also has great staff, amazing food and a cozy bar right in the Lobby of the Hotel. This past weekend I was there and Sunday was rainy and cold. I decided to grab a cocktail at the bar and had the nicest conversations with other customers, the owner of the restaurant and the bartender as well as the hostess and wait staff. Great service, great food and the prices are not at all excessive! I really need yo leave them a separate review!I highly recommend both the Montauk Manor and their in house restaurant.
-
December 2023 by Amanda Grace Petrocelli McLean
We came here for two mornings of our anniversary weekend away at the manor. The restaurant ambiance is very nice. They definitely need to work out some service issues. The first morning we were here was less crowded, second morning there were more people, and it took a very long time for us to be able to order food. We had to go up to the bar to ask for butter, syrup, and ketchup. My husband had to go fill up my water himself at the bar once, and I had to bring it back up. My husband ordered two entrees, eggs and pancakes. They forgot his eggs and had to send back his pancakes, because they were underdone. I was almost done with my omelette by the time he got his pancakes and he got his eggs as I was finishing the last bite. I will say that I had the omelette both mornings which was very good, and I enjoyed the home fries. French toast was eh (ordered that on the first breakfast). Pancakes were just ok, tasted like Krusteaz. Servers were sort of wandering around like they didn’t know who to serve or where to go. The manager had just come in to help with the food and was serving to the wrong tables. The first morning, we also overhead a different manager saying that the muffins should be covered, not just sitting on a plate out in the open. They were still sitting there uncovered the next morning. The manager ended up comping our bill and seemed very apologetic. Convenient breakfast, because we stayed at the manor, and it was right downstairs.
-
December 2023 by Richard D.
Great location and viewsExcellent staffRooms are a little dated bathrooms are worseExpected with the age of the hotel.Overall good stay
-
December 2023 by Annette G.
For anyone who really needs a relaxing getaway, I would recommend staying at the Montauk Manor, preferably off-season, after the summer crowds. They have specials where you can get beautiful accommodations for 4 days and pay for only 3. Each room & view is different so I recommend checking them out before finalizing your choice. We have gone there several times and haven't ever been disappointed. As far as the staff, they all are very kind and responsive.
