-
February 2024 by robert rising
Great guys walked in 2 min to closing and they got it
-
February 2024 by Andrew Bell
Very good classic pizza. They aren't chasing the coal fired, truffle, goat cheese trends - this is old school NYC style pizza.
-
October 2023 by Lefter Golemi
The best authentic Italian pizza in Westchester. Thank you
-
October 2023 by Richard Astacio
Really good slice in terms of texture and feel, but something is missing in the taste. Overall pretty good though.
-
June 2023 by Jose Otero
Great pizza been going there for years my old neighborhood still go there ?
-
April 2023 by Thomas Brooks
Oh 100% real spot. cash only. pizza is the best in the Whole Area, I normally don't eat in but they made me feel so fckn comfortable with the talks and etc that I really finished both my slices there, made it feel like I'm in my living room at home! True Italian Spot , You Will Get Love And You Will Hear Arguments, A True Italian Pizzeria!
-
March 2023 by Alejandro R.
John & Tony's has become my (almost) weekly go-to spot! Always made to order, and consistent in flavor and quality. The homegrown herbs used within the sauce has to be my favorite, followed by the quality of the dough.
-
February 2023 by LYDIA CHRUPCALA
Pizza is tasty but could use more sauce & less cheese.
-
January 2023 by A Awad
You don’t find places like this anymore
-
November 2022 by J C
Delicious old school pizza place, large pie was truly large
-
November 2022 by Avi Wacholder
Decent pizza.$32 family style salad???Cash only. Only bottled water.Parking: Minimal
-
October 2022 by Robert P.
Best pizza in Mount Vernon Area. Always fresh ingredients. I would definitely recommend this place. John knows Pizza. I've had pizza in Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, and the Bronx.
-
August 2022 by Food Rate
Old fashion Naples pizza, whole tomatoes not the crushed used in the sauce. BEST PRICE FOR SMALL PIE which is 16” (everyone else in the area sells as a LARGE pie). If you like to eat the crust in a pizza this is it!!Take a look at the photos, they speak for themselves! Amazing 21 years on the same spot! Pick-up, local deliveries except Monday (closed). The beautifully cute elder couple are pleasant & hardworking, respectful Napolitanos!!!
-
August 2022 by Charol Lovelace
Everyone has their usual pizza spots but I was in the area of John&Tonys…. What a blessing! I will never go back to my old pizza parlor. *This is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life (FACTS).#customer4life
-
July 2022 by Seth R.
Figured I'd give this place a try and I'm glad I did! Pizza was delicious! I ordered a pepperoni Sicilian you should expect an hr wait because the dough is made fresh but don't let that stop you, it's worth the wait not to mention there affordable prices. Whenever I have a pizza need John and Tony's pizza is the place I'll be going .
