Neversink General Store is a welcoming place that offers more than just gas. Inside, customers will find a clean environment with friendly staff who provide great service. The store features a deli with delicious home-cooked meals, including ribs, brisket, and Italian heroes, all at reasonable prices. Many visitors are impressed by the quality of the food, describing it as top-notch, with meat that falls off the bone and pizza that is very tasty. The store also carries a wide selection of local goods, drinks, and alcohol, making it a convenient stop for both passing travelers and locals. It functions as a full-fledged grocery and convenience store, providing everything needed from sunup to sundown. Customers appreciate that it is an oasis with excellent food and a variety of items, making it a go-to spot for lunch or supplies. While some mention occasional staff issues, many praise the store for its helpfulness and community support, especially noting their donations to local hospitals during COVID. Overall, Neversink General Store is seen as a friendly, reliable spot for good food and essential items in the area.