Thrift Stores near New Windsor, NY

9 locations found near New Windsor

“I have been going through my late husband's games and consoles wondering where could find someone who would give me a fair evaluation of what I had and what they were worth. As I searched online, Iconic Finds was mentioned multiple time and everyone agreed that the owner was very fair and knowledgeable. Turns out the store was only a few minutes away from my home. I messaged him and told him what I wanted to sell, and after a very pleasant exchange I let him know I would be by with my items. He carefully checked over everything and quoted me a price that was very fair. I couldn't be happier. Highly recommended!!!”

4.8 Superb49 Reviews

“I love our Good Will, everyone is very pleasant and helpful! I like the way they organize by color, I just wish they could group things by size also. You do have to look through every item, to find the correct size. Other than that suggestion, they keep everything neat & tidy are very helpful!”

4 Good96 Reviews

“That Nothing Be Lost Thrift & Antique Shop in Garrison, NY, is a hidden gem with four floors of unique finds, from antiques to gently used clothing. The shop has a welcoming atmosphere, and all proceeds support St. Christopher's Inn, helping those in need. Its also an excellent place to pick up Christmas and decorations downstairs. All merchandise comes from tax-deductible donations, and revenue supports the care and shelter of men in residence at St. Christopher's Inn.”

4.5 Superb62 Reviews

“We love to donate & to shop at Nifty Thrifty. The prices are amazing & the staff are wonderful! We drive in from CT & we always stop into Nifty Thrifty to donate & shop when we visit family in VT. We can't wait for our next visit! GREAT place!”

4.4 Superb31 Reviews

“Okay slay, this place has rejuvinated my soul. I never thought I'd find anything other than clothes at a thrift store and how wrong I was, not only did I find a copy of the grinch (2018), where Tyler the creator worked on the soundtrack, but I also found this really cute guinea pig looking fellow. Sometimes I can hear it skittering and panting at night. It walks to the window. It yearns.The employee's were very friendly and helpful!Yeehaw!I hope you check out this store, the hog yearns eternally.”

4 Good15 Reviews

“Such a great little place, with lots of little treasures to find. You can't beat the prices and all of it goes to help the kitties there in the store that are available to adopt, and they also help a bunch of local colonies. Such a hidden gem for you thrifters out there.”

3.6 Good24 Reviews

“This place was lovely! The workers were really kind and helpful. Everything was well-organized and clean. There are also some really interesting vintage knick-knacks from the donations that come in!”

3.5 Good81 Reviews

“So I read a few reviews before posting and I have to say that the bad ones seems to be ppl that cant be pleased.I have an ebay store as well but covid did a number on my business. This guy took a look at some of my things and gave me fair pricing overall.Extremely friendly and professional.And come on ppl he has a sweet little dog in his store. Dog ppl are good ppl lol.Great store and merchandise as well btw”

2.7 Average32 Reviews

“This place is a great place to buy clothes but there is a massive downside to shopping here. The Goblin. She is a middle aged lady with eyes of anger, she cuts in line, shoves people over, pushes you out of the way. Do not approach. She will never speak expect to yell at the top of her lungs across the floor. She smells like an old person home and when you ask her to please move over she acts like she forgot how to speak english even though she yells to her husband in english all the time. I’m not even exaggerating. Be warned”

3.3 Good131 Reviews