-
August 2025 by Sam Smith
A deliberate curio of culinary antiquity, the shop functions as both pantry and time capsule. Its deli case offers protein sliced to commissary-grade standards—rare in an era of pre-packed uniformity—while the confectionary aisle resurrects confections discontinued by mass distributors yet lovingly sourced by the proprietor. Equally notable is the interpersonal architecture: the owner greets each patron with the practiced warmth of a publican who has never subcontracted hospitality to union formalities, ensuring the transaction feels less like commerce and more like archived fellowship
-
July 2025 by rightdm00
Amazing subs and service
-
June 2025 by Kenneth smith
Love his subs , nice little selection of local amish foods
-
May 2025 by Micah Dunham
Great subs, Clark's Milk.
-
July 2024 by Karen Hovick
Best subs around
-
June 2024 by Sebastyan Dukaczewicz
Let me start this off by saying Daddy Al's has amazing subs. This is the first problem I've ahd with them. My sub order was a 12inch white sib with pastrami, liver wurst, rare roast beef, pepper jack cheese, mozzarella, mayo, spicy mustard, lettuce, hot banana peppers, black olive, and dill pickle. Out of this order they didn't add liver wurst, pepper jack, and hot banana peppers this is a lot that they didn't add. They didn't tell me they were out, if they did I could've added something else I wanted. Just check your subs to make sure they gave you everything you ordered.
-
May 2024 by Jeremy Sawyer
Love the subs and the hospitality ??
-
May 2024 by John Banks
For that quick stop in town .
-
April 2024 by Ryan Marshall
Best subs in Oneonta.
-
March 2024 by Terry Pineau
Filthy
-
February 2024 by Jason Lindroth
One of the local stores that sells old fashioned "Penny Candy". it is a good place to go to get squeezed out bags of Bavarian cream filling, strawberry pie filling, blueberry fillings for stuffing donuts as well as many other variations of pastries and desserts or even using for shakes/ice cream. they have a nice portion on there subs as well as nice selection of different types of meats cheeses. They do except over the phone orders as well as in person. There is an adjacent parking space close to the building locate off street. The staff always cheerful and pleasant to talk with. They have bulk bags of oats, confectionery sugar, sprinkles, chocolate wafers / coins, all kinds of cheese,and breads. they have a cooler section with drinks and both pre made salad and mix materials. There is so many more items that they have that might also be seasonal. so always got to check in to see what maybe a hidden treasure.
-
January 2024 by Traci Buckley
I love this place!! It’s like stepping back in history. Great subs! Great selection of Amish ingredients! Can grab Clark’s milk! And the customer service is top notch!! Thank you!
-
January 2024 by Gary Bedenharn
Great subs and using their sub cards
-
October 2023 by Angel Intorre
Good food good prices
-
July 2023 by Jessica Bunt
I love the old time candies!
