Buffalo Cigars is a highly recommended cigar shop that offers a relaxing and welcoming atmosphere for both novices and aficionados. Visitors praise the place as a spectacular spot to unwind with a cigar, complemented by quality adult beverages. The shop boasts a great selection of cigars, with friendly and knowledgeable staff ready to assist. Customers often highlight the exceptional customer service, with staff members going above and beyond to help find the perfect cigars and create a stress-free experience. One staff member, in particular, is frequently mentioned for being helpful, patient, and making customers feel at home, whether they are visiting alone or with friends.
The flagship location stands out for its calm, classy vibe, and clean environment. Visitors enjoy the outdoor garden with a patio, grill, bar, and games, which adds to the inviting atmosphere. The lounge area provides a cozy space to relax, and the staff often provide suggestions and tours that enhance the experience. Many customers express a strong desire to return, with some considering joining the cigar club to access exclusive features and events. The shop’s reputation is further enhanced by its popularity among local sports players and cigar enthusiasts alike. Overall, Buffalo Cigars is celebrated for its welcoming environment, quality selection, and excellent service, making it a top choice for cigar lovers in the area.
Excellent selection of fine cigars at reasonable prices.
I found Drew Estate Shade in the giant walk-in humidor.
This location has a nice complimentary lounge area for patrons to sit back, relax and enjoy their brand of cigars.
The staff is very friendly too.
August 2026
Always super helpful and a great meeting place for the boys.
August 2026
Buffalo Cigar in Orchard Park… being a member is great… monthly parties with raffles and drink specials… July pick roast was awesome. Sean and the staff are always helpful and care about their customers would recommend buffalo cigar……
